Skip to main content

No Russia for Rio? - WADA/McLaren report set to recommend blanket ban

On Monday WADA (World Anti Doping Agency) will publish lawyer Richard McLaren's report into allegations of widespread and systematic doping in Russian sport, and it seems very likely that they will recommend that Russia is banned from the Rio Olympics across all sports, including gymnastics, not just track and field as it is at present.  The allegations have been made by Dr Grigory Rodchenkov, former head of a Moscow anti-doping lab, based on his experience of testing at the 2014 Sochi Olympics.

WADA does not have the authority to ban a country from the Olympics, but if their report proves that cheating has been systematic and coordinated at the highest level, they can recommend sanctions to the IOC (International Olympic Committee).  The IOC has already enacted a ban against Russian track and field athletics, but whether they would consider banning a country across the entire range of Olympic sports is unclear.

'In May Mr. Bach [Thomas Bach, President of the IOC (International Olympic Committee] said he would apply a “zero-tolerance” policy and would not rule out bans against Russia across entire sports, like track and field. But last month he defended the Russian Olympic Committee, distancing the organization from the sports ministry. Dr. Rodchenkov, however, said he took direct orders from Russia’s deputy sports minister, Yuri Nagornykh, who is a member of Russia’s Olympic Committee.'

Russia's response to this is to emphasise and contextualise WADA's role in world sport - 

'Russia’s sports ministry has admitted to doping problems in recent months but denied government involvement. In an interview with The Times in Moscow this month, Vitaly Mutko, Russia’s sports minister, diminished the power of Mr. McLaren’s commission and WADA, which have the ability to make recommendations such as the ones the antidoping officials and athletes are prepared to do. The I.O.C. and sports federations have ultimate authority over who competes at the Games.

“Recommendations?” Mr. Mutko said. “It’s about the decisions. With respect to the commission, they do not determine the fate of world sport.”'

RRG's take on this?  It would be harsh to penalise all of the athletes from one country across all sports on the basis of evidence taken from a limited range of winter sports at a home Games.  The testing systems of other sports such as weightlifting have been found to be flawed on an international level, but have not attracted similar heavy sanctions.  Banning all Russian athletes across all sports would  be unjust and perhaps even unlawful given the limitations of the investigation and the time available for any necessary processes of justice.  
The recommendation to ban is essentially a sanction against Russia's flawed testing system, rather than providing justice for the individual athletes and sports affected, clean or not.

On the other hand, it is said that the report proves that the Russian Ministry of Sport has been ordering the labs to tamper with evidence.  If so, this questions Russia's ability to support its clean athletes - as well as to punish those who are cheating.  If the McLaren Report demonstrates that there is Government involvement in cheating, it may be difficult to argue in Russia's favour.  

It is unclear how the IOC will react, especially considering that the Games are only three weeks away, leaving little time for processes of justice to take place.  The Russian teams are travelling to Rio on the 24th July.  If gymnastics - one of the cleanest sports there is - loses out, it would be a tragedy not just for Russia, but for the whole of sport.  

You can read the latest reports on this developing story at the New York Times - follow this link - http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/17/sports/olympics/russia-doping-summer-games-rio.html?hp&action=click&pgtype=Homepage&clickSource=story-heading&module=first-column-region&region=top-news&WT.nav=top-news&_r=1

UPDATE 18.05 17/7 - Pat Hickey, Pres of the European Olympic Committee, doubts the fairness and independence of the McLaren report http://eurolympic.org/en/news-mobile-eng/3743-statement-by-pat-hickey-president-of-the-european-olympic-committees.html




Comments

  1. The Americans and their proxies have turned sport to an ugly political thing, it's unfair and political to impose a collective punishment on an entire country, and the next step they may ask to ban judges and referees from Russia also, why not? after all for them it's not about "doping test" it's about "nationality/political test" ...
    John

    ReplyDelete
  2. Here about little trainings from RL and all this shit from wada ! And believe me Kalugina is right about Farah and all these shit, coz a cant understand how in universe pice of doping like Gatlin can perform at Olympics and such clean athletes Kudreavtseva, Mustafina, Mamun, Melnikova or Isenbaeva not... IOC what are you doing!!!? http://vm.ru/news/2016/07/17/nashi-gimnasti-vistoyat-dazhe-esli-im-pridetsya-propustit-rio-326928.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. Not surprised!! Russia has always cheated in the sports, like sochi figure skating. I could say justice just finally arrives, not too late, but gymnastic with Russia and Larisa, I really don't know what to see in Rio!!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

More thoughts on US gymnastics, Karolyi - and Zaglada

I’d like to add some thoughts to my earlier post about USA gymnastics and Bela Karolyi:  1. What Bela did, he did. He would agree that his actions were his responsibility. 2. Abusive relationships in USA gymnastics (and no doubt elsewhere) pre-existed Bela’s move to the USA and still exist today. 3. Harsh training existed and exists in all of the ‘artistic’ sports and dance-related forms - eg ballroom dancing, ballet, ice skating, circus.  The training involved in most of these activities is founded on an assumption of the benefits of early specialisation.  It revolves around  ‘ideal’ forms, shapes and postures that are difficult to achieve without early years training - women especially.   4. Wherever prodigious early talent exists, there are predators whose main desire in life is to take advantage of that talent - music, entertainment, maths, sport.  The boundaries very easily become confused.  Who owns the talent?  Who decides how many hours to work, at what level?  FOR WHOSE BENEFI

Britain 1, Russia 2 in Junior European Gymnastics Championships

Sergei Eltcov, Kirill Potapov, Artur Dalolyan, Nikita Nagorny, Valentin Starikov It was a close-ish competition, but Britain came out on top everywhere as a team, except for pommel horse where the British had a bad day, and rings, a strong piece for a Russia.  In truth, they are two brilliant teams.  Many of these gymnasts will turn senior next year, swelling the ranks of their respective teams.  I can't wait to see them fight for medals at the a Rio Olympics.  Coached by two Russians (Andrei Popov and Sergei Sizhanov from the historic gymnastics city of a Vladimir), the British team carries the classical mark of the Russian school. CORRECTION - The British Junior team head coach is now Barry Collie.  

Tutkhalyan, Bondareva will fight to compete at Youth Olympics

Olga Bulgakova, courtesy of RGF Key points of a short interview with Olga Bulgakova, Head Coach of the national junior team http://www.allsportinfo.ru/index.php?id=83100 They had expected a little better result on floor and vault.  They need to review and change their tactics, work on the mistakes.  Bars and beam were the most successful pieces. The girls reached their minimum targets.  They use the results of competition for analysis, to understand where things aren't working, and correct any weaknesses. Seda Tutkhalyan and Maria Bondareva will be considered for the Youth Olympics in Nanjing.  Seda's programme is more complex.  But this was a major competition for both girls and both had errors.  There is still some work to do. Seda has complex routines, dealing with them is very hard.  If her routines had been less difficult of course that would have been easier to handle and she would be more stable.  But that wouldn't offer much promise.  She has a very promising progra

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more