Skip to main content

Andrei Rodionenko - Mustafina, Ablyazin and the judging in Antwerp - Lupita translates



Lupita translates this interview with Andrei Rodionenko.

Aliya Mustafina calculating Anna Rodionova's beam D value in Sunday's beam final
Andrei Rodionenko, standing in the bus that left the arena after Mustafina’s victory on beam, said that the Worlds in Belgium had not been a success.  It’s a good thing when the head coach judges himself uncompromisingly.  I myself don’t think it was a failure.

Some of the disappointments - Aliya not winning gold on bars, or Olympic medalist Ablyazin not making any final - have an interesting subtext. There are things that should rather be understood now. It’s better to correct them now, because repenting after Rio will be too late.

- Andrei Fyodorovich, as you were leaving the arena, you said laconically that “Nelli Kim has behaved aggressively”.  Out of the inquiries submitted, ours was ignored and the American complaint was accepted. Was Nelli Kim behind that, like three years ago in Rotterdam?

-  I would like to avoid blaming people. It leads nowhere. We should look for agreement. Of course, it’s difficult to understand why one country’s protest is taken and why the other is ignored. By the way, during the beam final the Americans submitted not one inquiry, but two! They also tried to challenge Simone Biles’ score! [ed – as well as Kyla Ross]. Yet, I don’t think mutual recriminations are the right way to go. I believe in dialogue in order to suppress the existing flaws or failures (let’s call them this).

- Are these failures?

- Sure.  As far as I am concerned, we need an accurate classification of elements. Like in Mendeleyev’s Periodic Table, or in diving.  Is creating a table with the value of each one of the elements so complicated a task?  Give me this table; give it to the judges, the gymnasts, the coaches, the audience. Complaints, inquiries will disappear. Mustafina has been working on the Shaposhnikova with a 1/1 turn for six months.  But this element has been judged like the Shaposhnikova with ½ turn that she performed in London.  Aliya has improved a lot since then. She put so much effort into that. But this doesn’t give her any bonus. Why?  They answer that we have to perform the element, and later they’ll see, and they’ll include it in the highest category (of elements). In such situations, both gymnasts and coaches work blindly. They master new complex tricks that don’t bring along any result.

- Does risk make sense?

-It’s not interesting without risk. In women’s gymnastics in Belgium, only China and Russia have shown something new. The rest, including the US, haven’t progressed. It’s true that the Americans win. But they don’t surprise. Every year they do the same. On the other hand, China … I think they deserve respect. They have brought a completely new team. Without aiming at medals, China came to test their gymnasts in the conditions of the new Code of Points. Even if the girls were of dubious age …

- Yes, one of them looked 11, no older …

- Yes, she had baby teeth (smiles) ... But they performed new routines. One Chinese gymnast, Lin Shaopan, shared gold with Uchimura. He was so relaxed, smiling, he fell, so what? The results were not important to him. He is a young all-arounder who won at the Chinese Championships. He made mistakes, but nobody considered this a disaster. It’s something normal. This is 2013! This is the first important competition on the road to Rio. Nothing else.

- You are vanquished …

- They want medals right now, more and more medals … Although, by the way, we fulfilled the medal plan we had privately established for ourselves.

- Andrei Fyodorovich, I heard some people blaming the Universiade participation … In Kazan I saw Fabian Hambuechen. He lost to Kuksenkov and said that he was too old for the all around. In Belgium he won a medal.

- Hambuechen only performed well on two events at the Universiade. He was not ready then. But he trained for Antwerp. Fabian’s example is not very good for another reason. The German gymnast has been performing the same routines for a few years. He made practically no mistakes. But, as I said, we have different goals. We want to make progress. I was talking here to the judges. It’s important to understand their approach, their criteria. Not everything is clear. For instance, equipment testing was carried out in a surprising way.  We had not been properly informed and were surprised, including Aliya …

- Can Aliya be surprised by something?

- Of course, she is a human being. Mustafina has her own way of warming up. She doesn’t like to train her routines 100% during warm up.  She preserves herself for the most important moments. She is not used to that. She was called for equipment testing.  Can you imagine?  She is not used to that.  They gave her a score and, later, during the whole competition, the details of her routine were stored in the computer. We were surprised when in the all around Mustafina performed better on beam than in qualifications, and got the same score. From the start the judges had worked it out.  Later they remembered this test routine, which normally everyone ignored, and were unable to put aside their first impressions.  There was something weird about the bars.  In the warm-up gym they were not on the podium, and their ‘behaviour’ is totally different on the floor. Before the finals, Aliya didn’t warm up.

- Andrei Fyodorovich, could you explain what happened to Ablyazin?

- Denis was outraged, we were all outraged … It’s the first time that he has failed his dismount from rings – double layout with double twist …

- Denis failed on his three events…

- I can explain this. Ablyazin has a fantastic technical level. He has always had problems in focussing himself. Denis is temperamental. Recently I told him: “My friend, I know what to do with you. Before the competition we have to take you to the arena and have you perform on all apparatus at a 200% level so that your level of performance will be 100%”.

Editor’s note: we are not completely sure what Rodionenko means by ‘equipment testing’ in this interview; sometimes he refers to it only as ‘testing’. 

Comments

  1. I think "equipment testing" is what we'd call "podium training" in English, judging by the context

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, but there is a Russian word for this which he repeatedly doesn't use. And I don't think Aliya would be surprised by podium training. We think it might have something to do with the testing of the judges' computer system, which explains what he then goes on to say about the practice score being stored in the computer. But we are not sure. It is unclear

      Delete
    2. Well, I need to know what that phrase "equipment testing" means! Please Queen, keep us updated :)!

      Delete
    3. My guess is the equipment testing is related to testing the computer stored memory of an routine. And my other guess is that Aliya was pick for testing that equipment is the sense of testing the whole routine with her full D score. Remember the he said that Aliya is not use in doing whole routine in warm-up.

      Delete
  2. It's an intriguing mystery that might never be solved :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. The longer the Rodionenko’s are involved in Russian Gymnastics the more hurt is going to happen to the team's preparation for Rio

    ReplyDelete
  4. I felt so terrible for Denis Ablyazin - he really is in the top 3 in the world in vault and floor (and not far from it on rings) in terms of sheer ability, but he's always let down by his focus. He could have done better in previous competitions, but this is the first time that he's really collapsed ... I'm glad I'm not Semy having to deal with that emotional fallout!

    ReplyDelete
  5. The caption for this photo is incorrect... Aliya was calculating her own D score, not Rodionova's.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cece, why? A close up of this picture shows the total to match Rodionova's D score, not her own ... More information please.

      Delete
    2. I was watching a broadcast of the EF at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=px-U4jcjBAI when this part came up at 17:54, Rodionova hadn't even performed yet but it was after Aliya's enquiry was rejected. It had something to do with that I think.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

More thoughts on US gymnastics, Karolyi - and Zaglada

I’d like to add some thoughts to my earlier post about USA gymnastics and Bela Karolyi:  1. What Bela did, he did. He would agree that his actions were his responsibility. 2. Abusive relationships in USA gymnastics (and no doubt elsewhere) pre-existed Bela’s move to the USA and still exist today. 3. Harsh training existed and exists in all of the ‘artistic’ sports and dance-related forms - eg ballroom dancing, ballet, ice skating, circus.  The training involved in most of these activities is founded on an assumption of the benefits of early specialisation.  It revolves around  ‘ideal’ forms, shapes and postures that are difficult to achieve without early years training - women especially.   4. Wherever prodigious early talent exists, there are predators whose main desire in life is to take advantage of that talent - music, entertainment, maths, sport.  The boundaries very easily become confused.  Who owns the talent?  Who decides how many hours to work, at what level?  FOR WHOSE BENEFI

Komova should have won!

It was a very tight battle in the North Greenwich arena today, with American Gabby Douglas beating out Viktoria Komova by a mere 0.259 points (see results below) and the legendary Aliya Mustafina sealing her comeback from that career-threatening injury with a well deserved bronze medal. Yes, she suffered a fall from beam after her Arabian somersault but elsewhere she was at her best, a real endorsement of the work of the Russian coaches in nursing her back to almost-top form since that fateful day in 2011. Komova had a faultless competition apart from a step on landing her Amanar vault. Frankly, she must feel utterly shattered after coming second once again by a very small margin to an American who was treated very generously by the judges. Komova soared and took every beam move to the max, rounding off with her rare double Arabian dismount in fine style; Douglas literally sidled along the beam, seeming frightened to take her feet off the apparatus for all but her somersaults. Kom

Britain 1, Russia 2 in Junior European Gymnastics Championships

Sergei Eltcov, Kirill Potapov, Artur Dalolyan, Nikita Nagorny, Valentin Starikov It was a close-ish competition, but Britain came out on top everywhere as a team, except for pommel horse where the British had a bad day, and rings, a strong piece for a Russia.  In truth, they are two brilliant teams.  Many of these gymnasts will turn senior next year, swelling the ranks of their respective teams.  I can't wait to see them fight for medals at the a Rio Olympics.  Coached by two Russians (Andrei Popov and Sergei Sizhanov from the historic gymnastics city of a Vladimir), the British team carries the classical mark of the Russian school. CORRECTION - The British Junior team head coach is now Barry Collie.  

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more