Skip to main content

Aliya Mustafina, a bronze medal, and Alexander Alexandrov - a review of the Russian press

Aliya Mustafina after last night's all around competition, where she won a bronze medal.  Courtesy RGF
2010 World Champion Aliya Mustafina put in an amazing performance last night, overcoming health worries and the significant pressure of being Russia's only feasible medal contender to win a bronze medal all around.  The USA were dominant in this competition, with Simone Biles taking gold ahead of team mate Kyla Ross in silver.  Simone had an excellent competition, and impressed with astounding power in her tumbles, including a double straight with half out.  You can find the results of the all around competition here.  I will be reflecting on the significance of this outcome later.

In the meantime, I wanted briefly to review the Russian press, which includes a couple of short interviews with Aliya, and an Itar-Tass discussion with Alexander Alexandrov, the first Russian language press coverage of the charismatic coach since well before his departure from Russia three months ago, and the first time that he has spoken in Russian about the reasons for his resignation, and his relationship with Aliya Mustafina.

Aliya Mustafina : 'I need better health' - interview with Elena Vaitsekhovskaya/Sports Express

She says that in order to do better against the Americans, she needs to be in better health, and to strengthen her vault. Everything in the AA final went as she planned. In qualifying she had been extremely nervous and shaky, but for some reason in the final she had felt that everything would turn out all right.
 

She speaks of the stability of the American girls and compliments Jinnan Yao as a nice girl and a good gymnast. Vaitsekhovskaya mentions that Grebyonkin seemed a little worried about bars final; Mustafina says she has a new programme; and that generally it takes at least a year for a new routine to bed in. She had been practising her gold medal winning Olympics routine for two years. When asked if she found it distracting to perform in a group with all the top gymnasts; especially when others began to fall off beam, she responded that she was only thinking of her own performance. And on floor, she says it was just her aim to finish off the day nicely, and to dance a little bit :-).

Aliya Mustafina : 'I was a little bit surprised by the beam score' - interview with I Rasskasova/Sovietski Sport


Aliya says that in beam qualifying she was much worse than in the final, and yet the score was about the same; she doesn't know how to understand it. But she doesn't like to question the judges; perhaps the routine looked different to outside observers to the way it had felt to her on the inside when performing it.

When asked about her floor performance, and whether she was completely satisfied, she said she was a little disappointed as she had failed to complete her triple Y turn. However, it is a new routine, so that's to be expected and she didn't want to get upset. Indeed, to the contrary, she went straight to Rodionova to help her to prepare for bars. She felt that Anna had performed well in her first major competition.

Alexander Alexandrov: 'I left Russia to shield Mustafina from non-sporting issues' - interview with Albert Starobutsev/ITAR-TASS 

In this interview Alexander revisits some of the points in his earlier interview about the reasons for his  departure from Russia, and talks about his work in Brazil.

He adds some points regarding the Russian team in Antwerp; that he is surprised that Grishina is not on the team; after her poor performance at the Olympics last year he expected she would be targeting these Championships; he felt that all of the girls from the Olympics should have been here, with the exception of Komova who has been ill. 

With reference to the team's participation in the University Games in Kazan, he says he does not feel that the competitive programme this year was too heavy, but that perhaps the training of the team needed to be planned differently. 

He emphasises that the only reason he left Russia was to protect Aliya Mustafina after Valentina Rodionenko had begun to make unfair statements about her to the press.  He adds that he has seen Aliya at these Worlds, they are on good terms; they embraced, and he wished her a happy birthday. Aliya's father has told him that Aliya will only ever have one coach: Alexander Alexandrov.

Comments

  1. I admire her. I think she deserved way better than a third place. She is a wonderful performer and a fierce warrior.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, I think that under this Code, she did remarkably well to achieve a bronze. But I like what Natalia Kalugina said: 'It was a bronze that was more expensive than gold'.
      It was a remarkable and very moving performance; I hope Aliya now takes some time off, but comes back reinvigorated and all the stronger for next year's Worlds.

      Delete
    2. First I want to say I love this website and the facebook version. I get all the best news on Russian gymnastics here. 2nd I want to add that I admire Russian gymnastics and enjoy watching them. 3rd I agree that I wish the Code of points would reward artistry more. But I get a little concerned when I see excuses being laid out like this and with similar complaints about judging.

      Are you saying that Aliya is incapable of getting anything higher than a Bronze because of the current code of points? Because I think she is a talented enough gymnast to keep her artistry and maximize her scores under any code of points. And I will admit I still see the old Soviet block vs. American block of judges and their suspicious scores, but I believe they even themselves out for the most part.

      I say this with all due respect because I enjoy this site, but I just had to get my thoughts out there on this subject.

      Sincerely,


      Todd

      Delete
    3. Hi Todd,
      Please bear wuth me ... A review of the outcome of this comp and its implications will be the subject of a future blog post. I am sure you will want to contribute to the discussion about that.
      Thanks for your words and I'll look forward to hearing your views.

      Delete
  2. She is definitely a warrior. She was able to pull out all the stops when it really mattered. We have seen her achieve this in many major competitions. Bravo!

    ReplyDelete
  3. One of my favorite moments of the WAG AA was when Aliya ADDED choreography when she paused on beam between the Onodi and the double turn. Don't think I've ever seen a prettier broken connection.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Simplemente una Reyna...elegancia, dificultad, gracia, belleza, poder. #1

    ReplyDelete
  5. She is so beautiful to me... not just when she added choreography and paused on BB between the Onodi and the double turn. She is the Queen! Just remember that sunshine always follows the rain, so wrap your troubles and dreams ... Because the troubles is not for the Queen!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Considering the crappy qualifier she had and illness and knee pain, she did very well. A healthy Mustafina could very well dominate and she has dominated many, many times over. She has a World All-Around title, plus the two that she won this year, four Olympic Medals, two European Golds. I was surprised that she didn't win the uneven bars gold.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well now she has won gold on beam.
      Which proves one good thing : talent will out, my dears!!! The Diva rules.

      Delete
    2. I can't describe how happy her beam gold makes me :D Really shows the world what she's made of! Aliya's a true fighter, and a beautiful one. Always comes out at the right moment :)
      Anyways, it's been a great worlds, hopefully she can get some real rest now. She deserves it.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Vladimir Zaglada - coach, author, friend, father

It is with great sadness that I report here the sudden and completely unexpected death, on 5th October, of our friend Vladimir Zaglada.  I send my love and condolences to his daughter, Olesya.  My thoughts are with the whole family.   Vladimir was born in Lvov, Ukraine, in November 1944.  His father was a progressive lawyer of great courage who was known to defend those who challenged the Soviet authorities.  Vladimir trained as a sports acrobat under the developing Soviet sports system, working in the same club as Olympic champion Viktor Chukarin.  After moving to Moscow, he became a leading coach of women's gymnastics, supporting the development of high level acrobatics.  He worked particularly closely with the up and coming young gymnasts of the early 1980s - you can see him at work in the video 'You in Gymnastics'.  At the national training centre, Lake Krugloye, he worked with Filatova, Mostepanova, Yurchenko, Arzhannikova, Mukhina and more.   Around the mid 1980s Vlad

Who really won the WAG All Around?

You will find a link to the FIG's newly published book of results at the Olympic Games here .  This year, they have broken down the judge's execution scores so you can see exactly how each judge evaluated the gymnasts' performances.  It makes for interesting reading - if only I had more time to analyse each judge's marking.  A skim reading already highlights multiple inconsistencies in individual judges' marks and makes you wonder why they bother with the jury at all. I have taken the time to look at the reference judges' scores for the top four in the women's all around.  The FIG explains here what their role is, and how they are selected.  I even used my calculator, which is a risky thing in my hands.  My, how I wish we could have seen a similar document for the Tokyo World Championships. I wonder if anyone can explain how, if the FIG's Code of Points is so objective and fair, it is possible to come up with two different results using two differ

Natalia Yurchenko - an exclusive interview

Natalia wins gold at the World Championships in Budapest, 1983 1983 World Champion Natalia Yurchenko speaks directly to readers of RRG in this exclusive interview.    Early years: In the summer of 1976, at the age of 11, I was accepted to a sports boarding school in Rostov-on-Don. I remember it was a 4-level building with the cafeteria on the first floor, academic classrooms on the second floor, rooms for girls on the third floor and rooms for boys on the fourth floor. There was one TV on the ground floor and the kids who stayed at school over the summer (about 20-30 kids), were able to watch the Olympics. Nadia Comaneci’s outstanding performance made us feel jealous because usually the Soviets were the unbeatable favorites. We did feel some relief with amazing performances from Nellie Kim and Ludmilla Tourischeva. Besides Ludmilla, there was a gymnast from Rostov-on-Don, Svetlana Grozdova! And, we were really thrilled to see the very little and cute Maria Filatova. B

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more