Skip to main content

Facts, lies and information

Three key members of the team - Komova, Mustafina, Paseka



The Russian press is so alive it's hard to keep track of all the coverage. I began this morning with a mission to review and post the most important links sent to me by the ever faithful M, by Alan Owen, and discovered by my own research, and have found myself 'painting the Forth Bridge' (the Scottish bridge that, it is rumoured, is impossible ever to complete painting because as soon as you reach one end, the other is in need of retouching).  It made me think about what we are all doing on the gymternet.






Read the title of the post if you wonder what I have been reflecting on specifically.  The net is full of information that has been reported and then passed quickly from reader to reader in a process of 'Chinese whispers'*.  News exchanges from person to person so quickly on the internet and often gains a life of its own. For example, on the 14th July I posted a Lupita translation of a Sports Express article in which national team coach Andrei Rodionenko was reported as saying that Nabieva had been injured the day before the control competition.  He also said that she didn't have the 2.5 Yurchenko vault that Paseka does have, thus sealing the selection fate of these two particular gymnasts. He didn't say how serious the injury was, or whether it had prevented her from competing in the control training and competition - just that she had an injury.

Now, of course, we have online stories of Nabieva's complete incapacity to compete for the team, disaster in the final days leading to her assignment as reserve (by the way, what would be the point having her as reserve if she couldn't compete?).  This, despite Oktiabr's astute observation that she was photographed practicing bars with the team the day AFTER Rodionenko had said she had become injured, albeit with a bandaged knee.

I do not think that anyone is lying about this; but it appears that Chinese whispers, a lack of clarity in communicating the uncertainty of the national team coach's original information, have led many to believe what might be questionable.

Does Rodionenko have any moral obligation to inform us gymnastics fans of the health of his gymnasts?  Do we have a right to hear the full story?  As bloggers, fans, posters on gymnastics forums, we are onlookers, unable to control what we see.  For most of us who do not compete or coach, our virtual interaction with news stories and with the gymternet is the only way we are active within this world.  There is a natural tendency to try to know everything we can know and to discuss, analyse and interpret that information to try to make sense of an incomplete picture.  But we are constructing our own reality.  The relationship of that reality to the lives of the gymnasts and coaches is undoubtedly somewhat moot.

Andrei Rodionenko and his wife, Valentina, are like chalk and cheese. Andrei R is a bubbling volcano of tension, drily humourous, speaks very comfortably on strategic matters but otherwise doesn't really give that much away.  His wife, on the other hand, is the exact opposite - dirpping in prime bits of information which she generously gives away left, right and centre.  I cannot find a picture of Valentina where she isn't obviously chattering animatedly, or gesturing expressively.  It is difficult to know what to think, which perhaps is the desired result.  Although, somehow, I suspect it is not a deliberate tactic.

But my, does Valentina create a lot of hot air (almost as much as John Geddert).  I do sympathise with Elfimov (see my earlier post) in wanting to calm things down a bit and be more realistic.  I just hope the rest of us will let him.

 

*Chinese whispers = you know, that game where you whisper to your friend 'we're having macaroni for dinner', and she whispers it to her friend and so on and so forth so that by the time all the friends have exchanged the whisper, the final person has heard 'I'm having a date with Paul McCartney'

Picture of the girls relaxing outside the Novodevichy Convent this weekend, by kind permission of the Russian Gymnastics Federation.

Comments

  1. Ha ha ha ! News about Nabz out and etc was funny : ) Its start to grow on other gymnastics blogs but i didn't want to stop it since people so love dramas i wondered what's gonna be next ABout Valentina Rodinenko she is so weird women ! Her information sometimes ridiculous she can't be trusted ! Did you read her last interview about Mustafina? http://www.sovsport.ru/gazeta/article-item/539148 Even people complain that her interviews better miss !

    ReplyDelete
  2. So true. You don't know what to think. I saw the rumors about Nabs, but again, I had read your article and didn't seem like anything was amiss, and I noticed pictures of her practicing on bars at the press send off thing. So I think she is fine. I think some people just mistranslated things because at the end of the article the writer wrote something like Nabs is recuperating her knee or something like that.

    That is the reason I don't like Valentina, she likes to talk way too much and she puts down the gymnasts in her own camp when she does. Like the new interview about how it's hard for Mustafina to watch Komova and Grishina or something like that. I doubt that is true and I don't know why she even says it. They need to ban her from the press, ban her from the girls. Her alone is causing them undue stress.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Queen Elizabeth. Do you need any translations of the interviews you translated with google.
    Lupita

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Lupi wil email if that's ok. am travelling at present. hope it is all going wel where you are. some have been done by russiangymnasts.net and there are a few new ones which i will filter but can't do a proper list till tomo. will explain. x

      Delete
  4. Best looking gymnastics team at the Olympics.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics

Svetlana Boginskaya, 15 years old, with her medals from the Seoul Olympics Nico translates the latest interview with gymnastics legend Svetlana Boginskaya, during a recent visit to her home country of Belarus. Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics, so now I ask for forgiveness from everyone who came in contact with me. The National Olympic Committee of Belarus held a press conference with three-time Olympic Champion in artistic gymnastics, Svetlana Boginskaya. The meeting was devoted to the 25th anniversary of the Olympic Games in Seoul. In South Korea the Belarussian won two gold medals in the team competition and vault. As a gift to the Olympic Hall of fame, the famous gymnast, now living in the United States, donated one of her trophies that she won at the 1990 European Championships and a pennant for Best Female Athlete of the USSR in 1989. How happy we were when we could share with such stars as Boginskaya, Scherbo, and Ivankov,...

Mustafina Interview 2 of 2 : 'I will only perform under the Russian flag'

Argumentyi i Fakti interview with Aliya Mustafina Translated by Marina Vulis ‘I have no fear’, says Aliya Mustafina.   ‘My father [Farhat Mustafin, the bronze medallist in Greco-Roman wrestling at the 1976 Olympics] took me to my first gymnastics class.   In his opinion children need to do sports, and he saw gymnastics as useful for my general development.   He had no goals – just to let us practice.’ It did not end with ‘just practice’ – she became the World Champion at 16, but then had an ACL injury the next year (2011) at the Europeans.   Even just returning to gymnastics is a feat; then she came back to win four medals at the 2012 Olympics. Aliya Mustafina – That injury.   I do not know why I was ashamed – so many people were watching me and I could not even walk.   My parents!   They saw everything on TV (the coach had to carry her from the podium).   Of course I was aware that anything could happen in gymnastics, but I di...

Fact or fiction? The press, gymnastics and pregnancy doping

It was a Sunday morning.  I was drinking my coffee and contemplating the day ahead - a workout at the gym, shopping for groceries, an evening reading a book, or catching up on last night's episodes of crime thriller The Bridge .  How nice it was not to have to think about work for a day. Then I saw it - a story about the history of doping in The Observer .  Interesting reading. Of course, cheating is as old as the hills.  It is, unfortunately, human nature for some people to try to gain easy advantage in any kind of competition.  That is why we have laws, rules, ethical guidelines.  People who cheat should face justice and shouldn't complain when they are found out. But the story about pregnancy doping bothered me.  Hadn't that been found to be fictional?  The author began with Olga Kovalenko's allegations made in 1994 - but the rumours had started way back in 1991 with the documentary series More Than A Game .  The practice...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more