Skip to main content

Who needs difficulty? Portraits of a young gymnast - Ivan Stretovich

These pictures of young Ivan Stretovich, taken by Elena Mikhailova at last week's European Gymnastics Championships, are available in a gallery at the Russian Gymnastics Federation website.  I wanted to share a sequence of them with you.

Stretovich turns 16 in October, and comes from Novosibirsk in Siberia, where he is coached at the Dynamo club by B Konvissar.  This young gymnast emerged at April's Russian Championships, where he took gold or silver medals in every event final except for vault.  In Montpelier, he contributed to the Russian team's silver medal.

But pictures speak louder than words, and medals aren't all that matters.  Stretovich's start values (in qualifying 5 (F), 5.1 (PH), 4.8 (SR), 5.4 (V), 5.1 (PB) and 4.9 (HB) leave some room for development, but the special quality of his work is even rarer than a double twisting double back somersault.  That quality is the ability to elevate the simple to a pitch of perfection, and to make the difficult look simple: consider here the amplitude, line, pointed toe, outstretched hands, that exquisite positioning of the head, the alignment of the shoulders.  The Code should value this ability more highly than it does: who needs difficulty when simple gymnastics can be this beautiful?


Little wonder that Valentina Rodionenko occasionally gets a little stroppy about standards of international judging, when you compare this junior gymnast's performances to those of some of the senior elite women who are regularly scoring in the high 50s all around.

I know I should be updating the results from the senior event finals, but this picture sequence seemed even more important to me at this particular time.  You will probably all know by now that Garibov and Balandin both achieved gold medals on their events (high bar and rings), and that Ablyazin achieved two bronzes on floor on vault.  I will provide a fuller account tomorrow.

Comments

  1. that picture of Raismann.. well, she does get heavy deductions for her form on every international podium, and I must say that the judges have gotten quite good in recognizing and appreciating artistry over difficulty (Ksenka's golden floor at worlds or even Liukin's bronze on floor at the Olympics or her floor score in the AA- her tumbling form was always horrendous and yet..) Let's hope that London judges keep a close eye on the sheer execution beauty of our team. May the best ARTISTIC gymnast win!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you, Quenn Elizabeth on behalf of my Russian compatriots from around the World. I didn't found any tributes to the young Russian gymnasts yet except portrait you wrote and shared with us. You are the first again saying such a good words about future of World Gymnastics. Just one example: Ablyazin got bronze with an incredible difficulty on FX? Surprise? Not at all. I am not making a special research about deductions and mistakes. I am talking in general: why he would need to perform so many difficult tumbling passes having just a carpet with four corners? Is it the only one existing way to make Artistic Gymnastics more attractive for the young people making just a first steps into the difficulty? Is the real future of the FX looks like a 12 - 15 different tumbling passes performed on 4 - 6 Road Floors connected to each other? I really don't think so. I hope that very soon your voice will sound much louder because it is not a real fun to see Artistic Gymnastics without Artistic!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Don't the judges notice breaks in Iordache's execution (every jump... feet, arms!!!), in Ponor's (toepoint!!! everywhere), the American team...?
    It's often easy to understand Rodionenko's reaction!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you both for your comments.
    I think that the value of Stretovich's work goes beyond form and needs to be understood in a number of different ways (choreography, harmony, amplitude, line etc??).
    Form deductions for lower level work can't really assess fairly work that is at a higher level. A human simply can't enumerate all of the deductions within the time frame available to judge international routines; and the beauty of this work goes beyond an absence of errors.
    Surely it is about finding a way to reward virtuosity, and providing a positive bonus to the better gymnast.
    There is such an over-emphasis on difficulty but the Code and the judges have also lost sight of the essential need to assess intuitively and respond to what is visually the better gymnastics.
    It's such a tragedy that the FIG abolished compulsories - they really did provide a great baseline for discriminating performance level which also helped when it came to marking the optional exercises.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that the refereeing is better now than it was a perfect score but it would be fairer to bid up some sort of bonus for virtuosity

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

‘We all love her very much’ - Roschina speaks of Mustafina and the need to perfect an Amanar vault

From sport.ru via vk.com.  Google translate  A big interview with Anastasia Loginova from Sport24 with Lyudmila Roshchina following the Strongest Cup, where the gymnast won four out of five gold medals. We quote several fragments, the full version is available on the publication's website, link at the end. ❓ The Strongest Athletes Cup has recently ended. Did you have time to analyze your performances? 💬 I just rewatched the broadcast, looked at my shortcomings. ❓ Did you set a medal plan for this start? 💬 I didn't think about it. Only that I needed to do my program - and then what will happen. ❓ Did you have time to discuss the competition with your coach? 💬 She praised me, said that I was great. She didn't scold me for mistakes on the beam - on the contrary, she supported me. ❓ Can we say that the beam is your weak spot? This is the only final you didn't get to. 💬 Probably yes. I have this apparatus that is a bit unpolished, so to speak. Treacherous. I need to work...

Simone and the others - results and reflections

In the end, it was as predicted : Simone and the others, with Simone's teammate, Alexandra Raisman, providing the back up.  I do not need to point out that, by definition, the Americans are scoring significantly higher marks than the rest of the field.  Congratulations to them! Aliya Mustafina finished in third place.  The 2012 bronze medalist led the competition after vault and uneven bars, but had a very nervous outing on beam that might have taken a less experienced gymnast out of the medals.  A bravura performance on floor brought Aliya back though to confirm her third place all around.  From her senior debut in 2010 to today, Mustafina has continuously set high standards of grace.    It is the first time since 2000 that a gymnast (Amanar) has medalled in the all around at two consecutive Olympics, and  if Aliya can medal on Saturday's uneven bars final, she will once again be Russia's biggest medal winner of the women's gymnastics.  Russ...

AA Champion Liudmilla Roschina targets Olympic gold

  Liudmilla is the first gymnast of the new generation to win AA in the most important international competition in Russia.  The Krasnodar born gymnast was at one time said to be the favourite of head coach of the junior team, Aliya Mustafina.   Source: gymnastics group on VK.com.  Google translate Lyudmila Roshchina shone at the "Strongest Athletes Cup" in artistic gymnastics in Moscow.  🔝 The 17-year-old gymnast became the absolute champion in the all-around and in individual disciplines, winning the vault, parallel bars and floor exercises!  "I am very pleased. There were small mistakes, but they did not prevent me from showing a decent result. I liked the atmosphere of the competition, the full stands helped when I went out on the apparatus. I love all the apparatus, but especially the parallel bars. And, of course, it was interesting to test myself against foreign rivals. In September, the Russian Championship will be held, I want to perform there at ...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more