Skip to main content

Aliya Mustafina and Alexander Alexandrov - Wonderwall

A montage from E007y that just about says it all when it comes to this compelling coach/gymnast pair.  I do so love these videos.



And go to Gymnastike to view a video of the Russian team in training with Alexandrov at the 2011 World Championships.  They look disciplined enough to me.

Apparently the sports federations have meetings with Russian Sports Minister Vladimir Mutko on Monday to analyse the results of the Olympics and development plans for the coming years.  At this meeting the decisions of the Coaches' Council of the Russian Gymnastics Federation will be discussed, including the re-allocation of coaching responsibilities.  In an article in Izvestia, Alexandrov has said that the meeting was secretly videotaped, suggesting that the proceedings and decision to let him go were rigged.  I do not know if Mutko can overturn the decisions taken or suggest further or alternative measures be taken to re-establish calm and discipline at Lake Krugloye.

We'll continue to try to do what we can to find some clarity in this knotty situation.

Comments

  1. Bárbara de Chile29 September 2012 at 23:48

    The only word I have in my mind is JEALOUSY, jealousy from his own colleagues, and in my opinion, Valentina´s furious jealous that conquered everyone in the team...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree Barbara, especially the part about Valentina.
      OK, review the coaches' responsibilities, but there is no need to seek to humiliate Alexandrov publicly. And what is being said is either implausible or so lame as to be laughable. The Rodionenkos have been watching too much Make It Or Break It, or reading too much into podium training reports on Gymnastics Examiner.
      Make staff changes if you want - but do them in the right way and leave people with some wiggle room so they can keep working. Most of all, don't drag the gymnasts into it.
      I so want Aliya to win everything in the next quad with Alexandrov as her coach, just to silence Valentina.
      Who will be 80 by the time of the next Olympics by the way. Her husband 74.

      Delete
    2. Bárbara de Chle2 October 2012 at 17:50

      Elizabeth, do you know what happened to Leonid Arkaev? As team coach, I remembered he was Prodounova´s personal coach (and step-father), and before that, Galieva´s one? After Sidney 2000, I never see him again...

      Delete
    3. Hi Barbara, I think Leonid continued as head coach of the Russian team until 2004. He is now Director, Head Coach, and God (as far as I can tell) of gymnastics in his home town of Saransk.
      He has three jobs and says he enjoys being busy. After being forced to step down as head coach he was disappointed, but he loves his new jobs and wouldn't go back to being a national coach - it was a very worrying responsibility.
      I'm pretty sure I saw him at the London Olympics and there are a couple of profiles of him on this blog. I have always liked Leonid.

      Delete
    4. Bárbara de Chile2 October 2012 at 19:10

      Thanks for your answer!! I´ll see the profiles of your blog! It´s great to know he continues on Gymnastics, he is a legend!
      I hope Alexander stays in Russia, I have nightmares about a second departure to the US... that would be extremely disappointing...
      Have you ever met Vika, Aliya or some other russian gymnast? The only international elite gymnast I met once was Daniele Hipolito in a World Cup here in Chile, and well, Tomas Gonzalez (since he was 14)

      Delete
    5. Hi, I interviewed Shushunova, Artemov, Arkayev and Alexandrov back in 1989 - must try to find them so I can post here. Haven't met any of the others personally. Put that down to my British reserve, the sport is really friendly.

      Delete
  2. When coaches are encouraged to slander other coaches, camaraderie dissolves and, sadly, so does the support system that anchors these young athletes.

    [Whether a success or failure at the last competition] "You have support from your friends, your personal coach, the head coach, your family. All this helps to fight to overcome your nerves and fear." - Anna Dementyeva

    "Everyone just sees us compete. But it's really not just us. It is our coaches. And it's our family, and everyone back home that's supporting us. Without him [personal coach Mihai Brestyan] and [wife] Sylvia none of it would have been possible." - Aly Raisman

    It will probably take longer than the next Olympics to clean up the Chernobyl disaster that is happening in the women's program. Moreover, once it has been contained, and trust somewhat restored, finding a leader who is amicable to all and talented enough to bring the program back to preeminence may require another quad (or two).

    "Without question, the accident at Chernobyl was the result of a fatal combination of ignorance and complacency." - CHERNOBYL by Richard Rhodes

    This is a haunting assessment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ouch.
      I keep envisioning a scenario where Alexandrov heads West, taking Mustafina with him only to return to Russia for qualification events.
      Rodionenko has confirned that younger coaches are thin on the ground in Russia. I wonder if we will see a more individualised training regime develop, a little like tennis where talented players travel to be with coaches overseas.
      Looks like the team spirit has well and truly broken down. That's sad. I hope they can find some sticking plaster to glue it together. Not only does Russia need a good team of coaches, the world needs Russian gymnastics to elevate the sport beyond mere athleticism.

      Delete
  3. Just leaving this https://dl.dropbox.com/u/68120809/Russian%20TV%20report%20on%20Alexandrov.m4v
    Maybe Lupita can translate. Looks interesting, for sure. It's from last weekend, I think, reporting on the whole situation, with the recordings from the coaches council.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The quality of the recording is surprisingly good for a meeting that was secretly videotaped...

    ReplyDelete
  5. I must confess I find watching that video quite upsetting, in particular the posture and facial expressions of Alexandrov who was visibly distressed throughout, the use of Mustafina as an example of poor behaviour, and the sickening theatricals of Zelikson - who has really achieved very little as a coach but obviously really loves the sound of his own voice. Considering that he is now no longer even personal coach to an underachieving Olympian ...
    Lupita is very busy at present with work commitments - if this can be translated, it will be, but I'm not sure it really adds anything more to what has already been said.
    We are now really just waiting to see whether Sports Minister Mutko makes any statement, and to hear what Alexander Alexandrov finally decides about his own position as personal coach of Aliya Mustafina.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is interesting http://www.mk.ru/sport/article/2012/10/04/757209-aliya-mustafina-kak-yabloko-razdora.html (Aliya Mustafina - a bone of contention)
    Besides the nice pics of coach and pupil, it's yet another recap of what has happened until now, plus some questions about Aliya's future and Alexandrov calling the whole "you can't have a personal student" thing a non-issue.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Valentina Rodionenko on Alexandrov's dismissal - Lupita translates

76 year old Valentina Rodionenko.  Picture courtesy of the RGF . Read below Lupita's translation of what Valentina Rodionenko had to say yesterday evening about the current staff changes at Russian Gymnastics, from Sovietski Sport . Valentina Rodionenko : Alexandrov stays as coach to Mustafina. Therefore, he is not allowed to be a national coach! Head coach Valentina Rodionenko commented on Alexander Alexandrov’s dismissal specially for “Sovietski Sport”.   - Alexandrov hasn’t been fired. You don’t need to make up things like that. We have been assigning the duties. When we dismissed Leonid Arkaev, it was decided that the team’s coach doesn’t have the right to be a personal coach at the same time. Alexander Sergueievich combined both functions, but it was against the rule. Now we have eliminated this. - In an interview with “Sovietski Sport”, Alexander Alexandrovich said that he had been blamed for working poorly. Do you personally think that he d...

Elena Produnova - interview

The gymnastics group at VK.com has published an interview with 2000 Olympian, Elena Produnova.  Thanks for their permission to provide an edit of it here. People will remember Elena in particular for two reasons: her original vault that no one else has been able to emulate; and her own special brand of powerful  acrobatics, energetic temperament and musical flow, a heady mixture that today's gymnasts find impossible to match. Recently there have been some photographs of Elena working in a gym.  Although she has always said that she wouldn't have a coaching career, it seems that now she is a coach at a gym in Nalchik,  a town in the very south of the Russian Federation, in the foothills of the Caucasian mountains, in the republic of Kabardino-Balkaria.   The first question, tell us how you ended up in Nalchik? - Nalchik came up at the right time, in terms of my life circumstances.  Through my previous work I had a very good friend - head of the sports depart...

Aliya Mustafina - new interview

Aliya in her new Olympic Games outfit.  The teams were kitted out at the Bosco Olympic centre in Moscow last week 'Europeans went quite well, for me personally and for the team.  There were no big blunders or falls and we were able to show a good result.  If we continue to work in the same way as we approach the Olympics, everything will be fine ... Although of course we will need to do a little more in Rio.  For the Olympic Games, everything will be right. 'My knee [Aliya suffered a torn meniscus for which she had surgery last November] is all right, there are no problems with it, I am not worried. 'We will try to fight for first place. But we will be happy with any medals . As usual, our main rivals will be the teams of America, China and the UK. 'It will now be very, very difficult to fight Simone Biles [in the AA] because she has a very large D score. In general, in the individual competition, my goal is just to perform well. The most important thing in the Olymp...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more