Skip to main content

Russian team prospects and a proliferation of question marks

Putting aside worries about injuries, we have seen this year how the deselection of certain gymnasts from competition rosters can influence competition outcomes and delay the often simplistic conclusions we gym fans want to draw.  Komova's lack of appearance on the senior front leaves us completely befuddled and Mustafina's sudden withdrawal from the European Championships beheaded Russian, European and, arguably, World gymnastics.  We are unsure whether these two gymnasts can possibly make it back to their former level and Dementyeva now appears as the poster girl of the forthcoming Russian Cup competition.  However, she might as well have a giant question mark over her head for all the credit she is given for her achievements.

Similarly, the recent EYOF was without its top contender (Anastasia Grishina) and her closest domestic rival (Anastasia Sidorova), leaving us wondering how the results would have been affected if the Russian team had included those we consider to be close to unbeatable on the European stage.  Larissa Iordache, the strong leader of the European junior field at this competition, will now suffer the same fate as Dementyeva as her achievements are questioned thanks to the absence of two of her rivals.  Is this placing of question marks part of a pattern?  Will we have any reliable indicator of the Russians' competitive form before the European Championships next year?

There is not much point in over-stating the Russian women's prospects at the up coming World Championships, but I do not believe they are as poor as many state, including Alexandrov.  Nevertheless, there are some benefits in building up slowly towards the Olympics.  A gymnastics team is only as good as its reserves; if a team cannot win without its leading performer, then the chance of leading the sport more than momentarily is pretty poor.  Injuries are to be expected and team training and selections should take this into account.  I would be surprised if they don't.

Interesting to see the women's team selection for EYOF.  I know that the two Anastasias were supposedly injured, but this was clearly a 'new generation' team, selected from Republics infrequently represented on national teams, with two girls from the same club.  These gymnasts were amongst the stand outs in the recent Spartakiade, but I wonder if there was any deliberate strategy involved?  I remember the excellent Ekaterina Privalova, who despite some rather good results at national competition repeatedly missed out on international assignments thanks to the impoverished state of her local republic.  Hopefully the wider geographical spread of home clubs represented by girls on the national team is an indication of wider reaching financial provision for the sport.  Putin has publicly nailed his colours to the post of sports funding and is expecting Olympic medals as part of a long term funding strategy to 2020.

I was quite surprised to read Alexandrov's rather calm dismissal of the Russian women's chances at Tokyo, supported by a statement that it's difficult to get the girls to work hard when there is little competition for a place on the team.  I agree to the extent that I do consider qualification for the Olympics to be the most important outcome of Worlds this year; but to admit that your team isn't really working as hard as it might is a bit of a weak admission, if that is what he is really saying.  Or perhaps there is some kind of subtle psychology going on that I don't understand. 

Let's hope that the upcoming Russian Cup will provide a few answers as to the form of Afanasyeva, Semenova, Nabieva, Dementyeva and Belokobylskaya.  With a revived Komova, this could form the core of the Russian team.  And it's not a bad one, is it?

Comments

  1. Really interesting article thanks :) I hadn't realised Privalova had missed out on international assigments because of the state of her home republic (which one was it out of interest?)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Rachel, I believe she was from the city of Samara - the same home town as Anna Dementyeva!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice article. I don't understand why the mention of Fukushima though. Worlds will be in Tokyo. They are more than 200Km from each other @@

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oooh ... brain drain ... such a silly mistake, I have made it elsewhere. Will correct! Thanks.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics

Svetlana Boginskaya, 15 years old, with her medals from the Seoul Olympics Nico translates the latest interview with gymnastics legend Svetlana Boginskaya, during a recent visit to her home country of Belarus. Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics, so now I ask for forgiveness from everyone who came in contact with me. The National Olympic Committee of Belarus held a press conference with three-time Olympic Champion in artistic gymnastics, Svetlana Boginskaya. The meeting was devoted to the 25th anniversary of the Olympic Games in Seoul. In South Korea the Belarussian won two gold medals in the team competition and vault. As a gift to the Olympic Hall of fame, the famous gymnast, now living in the United States, donated one of her trophies that she won at the 1990 European Championships and a pennant for Best Female Athlete of the USSR in 1989. How happy we were when we could share with such stars as Boginskaya, Scherbo, and Ivankov,...

Who really won the WAG All Around?

You will find a link to the FIG's newly published book of results at the Olympic Games here .  This year, they have broken down the judge's execution scores so you can see exactly how each judge evaluated the gymnasts' performances.  It makes for interesting reading - if only I had more time to analyse each judge's marking.  A skim reading already highlights multiple inconsistencies in individual judges' marks and makes you wonder why they bother with the jury at all. I have taken the time to look at the reference judges' scores for the top four in the women's all around.  The FIG explains here what their role is, and how they are selected.  I even used my calculator, which is a risky thing in my hands.  My, how I wish we could have seen a similar document for the Tokyo World Championships. I wonder if anyone can explain how, if the FIG's Code of Points is so objective and fair, it is possible to come up with two different results using two differ...

Rodionenko responds

Rodionenko about Melnikova’s words about the level of gymnastics in Russia: “Such comments are not from a great mind. I don’t think Angelina has the right to judge.” The coach criticized Angelina Melnikova for her words about the level of Russian gymnastics. Earlier, Olympic champion Melnikova said: “In Russia there are two or three gymnasts who can qualify for the level of the European and World Championships, the rest cannot. The level of competition in Russia is also low.” “I am skeptical about her comment. I don’t think that Angelina has the right to judge the state of gymnastics in Russia and talk about who can qualify for prizes. We have enough competition, it is no coincidence that Angelina was only third at the Russian Cup. Such comments are not from a great mind. We are Olympic champions in team competitions. Not individually, but as a team! This is a special victory and it says a lot. That’s all,” said senior coach of the Russian artistic gymnastics team Valentina Rodionenko....

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more