Skip to main content

Who will fill the gap?

As I watched Aliya Mustafina prepare for her vault at that fateful competition, resplendent in her royal blue leotard and waspily striped leg warmers, I was reminded of the girl's fearsome heritage, both ethnic and sporting.  Her darkly curlicue features, the fine set of the cheekbone, the intense imperiosity of Mustafina's gaze are redolent of a proud Tatar princess. Put the cornrows back in her hair, add a tiara and a few jewels to that corsage and you are more than halfway there.   Huddled close to coach Alexandrov, her demeanour was that of a prize fighter ready for combat.   Mustafina is her father's daughter (Fargat Mustafin was an Olympic medallist in Greco Roman wrestling).  

It would be easy to forget that Mustafina, not yet 17 years old, only graduated to the senior national team in January 2010.  And that she is the first Russian woman in many years to make the transition from junior to senior without succumbing to the pressures and ending up as an also-ran.  Her success seemed to represent a significant turnround in the fortunes of a Russian gymnastics team which had rarely been able to demonstrate competitive consistency to match its often unrivalled flair.

The pace at which she had developed her difficulty since last spring appeared almost inconceivably precipitous, and the manner of the Queen's accession to the throne had been equally, if not more, astounding: the conscious ability to produce her best when under pressure is what marks Mustafina out as special.  I can think of only one gymnast - Shushunova - who has demonstrated similar qualities.  If Mustafina does not succeed in regaining her competitive form and returning to the highest level, it will be a tragedy for gymnastics as she brings a note of combat to a sport which otherwise can tend to be just a little too twee and polite.  We all know that gymnastics is a hard sport, but Mustafina's feisty spirit challenged others to dare to beat her.

Her current absence from the international stage diminishes gymnastics' interest for many fans, but Mustafina's absence from the Russian team could become emblematic of more than this unless the 'others' can find the Mustafina spirit in themselves at this year's World Championships and beyond.  I am sure it is inevitable that their gold medal count will suffer somewhat in her absence, but now that Komova's participation in worlds seems moot, the remaining Russians will have to be at their best to guarantee qualification to the Olympics, and at best ensure that they enhance the team's reputation for strength in depth.

So who will step up and fill the huge gap left by this super-motivated athlete?  A huge question mark hangs over the head of Tatiana Nabieva, who as recently as 2008 beat Mustafina to the title of Junior All Around European Champion.  Yet recently Nabieva seems to have dropped her all around ambitions, preferring to be a specialist.  Is she truly happy with this role?  Anna Dementieva appears ready to take over the reins of leadership of the Russian team, and is certainly their top all around prospect at present.  But could Nabieva also revert to the role of all arounder, and pull herself back to equal the competitive level of Mustafina?  Or will the beautiful, but unpredictable, Afanasyeva be more reliable and motivated?  In the wake of Mustafina's clear superiority, has Nabieva chosen to step down to a minor role rather than face up to the uncomfortable reality of fighting her best friend for medals?  Has Tanya given up, just a little? 

In an interview at the end of last year she explained that her task was to improve her stability and strength.  She certainly seems to have achieved that in early competitions this year, but what next for Nabieva? As a junior she regularly fought and won all around competitions against her best friend.  Is she still as happy as she appears with the secondary role to which she has assigned herself?  Is her psychological contribution to the team's wellbeing as important as her gymnastics these days?  Tanya, I feel, is the great unknown of the Russian team.  Is she underachieving?  Is she capable and willing to do more?  The longer her fringe grows, the more I wonder ...

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

More thoughts on US gymnastics, Karolyi - and Zaglada

I’d like to add some thoughts to my earlier post about USA gymnastics and Bela Karolyi:  1. What Bela did, he did. He would agree that his actions were his responsibility. 2. Abusive relationships in USA gymnastics (and no doubt elsewhere) pre-existed Bela’s move to the USA and still exist today. 3. Harsh training existed and exists in all of the ‘artistic’ sports and dance-related forms - eg ballroom dancing, ballet, ice skating, circus.  The training involved in most of these activities is founded on an assumption of the benefits of early specialisation.  It revolves around  ‘ideal’ forms, shapes and postures that are difficult to achieve without early years training - women especially.   4. Wherever prodigious early talent exists, there are predators whose main desire in life is to take advantage of that talent - music, entertainment, maths, sport.  The boundaries very easily become confused.  Who owns the talent?  Who decides how many hours to work, at what level?  FOR WHOSE BENEFI

Komova should have won!

It was a very tight battle in the North Greenwich arena today, with American Gabby Douglas beating out Viktoria Komova by a mere 0.259 points (see results below) and the legendary Aliya Mustafina sealing her comeback from that career-threatening injury with a well deserved bronze medal. Yes, she suffered a fall from beam after her Arabian somersault but elsewhere she was at her best, a real endorsement of the work of the Russian coaches in nursing her back to almost-top form since that fateful day in 2011. Komova had a faultless competition apart from a step on landing her Amanar vault. Frankly, she must feel utterly shattered after coming second once again by a very small margin to an American who was treated very generously by the judges. Komova soared and took every beam move to the max, rounding off with her rare double Arabian dismount in fine style; Douglas literally sidled along the beam, seeming frightened to take her feet off the apparatus for all but her somersaults. Kom

Britain 1, Russia 2 in Junior European Gymnastics Championships

Sergei Eltcov, Kirill Potapov, Artur Dalolyan, Nikita Nagorny, Valentin Starikov It was a close-ish competition, but Britain came out on top everywhere as a team, except for pommel horse where the British had a bad day, and rings, a strong piece for a Russia.  In truth, they are two brilliant teams.  Many of these gymnasts will turn senior next year, swelling the ranks of their respective teams.  I can't wait to see them fight for medals at the a Rio Olympics.  Coached by two Russians (Andrei Popov and Sergei Sizhanov from the historic gymnastics city of a Vladimir), the British team carries the classical mark of the Russian school. CORRECTION - The British Junior team head coach is now Barry Collie.  

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more