Skip to main content

FIG clears Vera Kiryashova of judging impropriety

   Coach and judge Vera Kiryashova with one of her world champion gymnasts, Tatiana Nabiyeva




TASS (Albert Starodubtsev) reports that Russian WAG judge Vera Kiryashova has been cleared of biased judging at last year's World Championships.  The well known judge, also coach to champions Tatiana Nabiyeva and Elena Eremina, stood accused by the Women's Technical Committee of overscoring the beam routines of Maria Kharenkova, Seda Tutkhalyan and Viktoria Komova.   All expenses were reimbursed in respect of the disciplinary hearing (1,000 Swiss Francs).

Olympic licenses have already been handed out to judges, and Mrs Kiryashova was denied hers in favour of her compatriot Maria Ulyankina (personal coach to Maria Paseka and Seda Tutkhalyan) pending the result of the disciplinary hearing.  She says that she will not pursue its reinstatement as that would involve denying her colleague the opportunity to judge at the Games.  'I was banned from the Olympics before any investigations had taken place', said Kiryashova, 'even though my work to date had been rated as excellent by the FIG'.

Vera Kiryashova was assigned to work as an execution judge in team qualifications at Glasgow Worlds.  Details of the WTC's allegations were made available to Kiryashova in a letter of 25th March.  The disciplinary hearing took place in Lausanne on 11th May.  

Source - http://tass.ru/sport/3339206

Comments

  1. Sad that Russia might be getting a bad reputation over this

    ReplyDelete
  2. and what did the Women's Technical Committee do with the genius judges in UB final and their festival "Gold-for-all"??? in my opinion it has been turned to a political thing in AG for a while now and I stopped trusting their judges' scores...
    John

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I thought that the Code had been designed to be impartial, transparent and 'objective'. Instead of which it simply demands uniformity, it seems. Poor Kiryashova.
      I cannot find the details of this hearing on the FIG site - I wish they would publish them - it would help understanding and make them more transparent.

      Delete
    2. Queen E, do you know who or what brought about the investigation in the first place? Does the FIG solely think to review judges or would a particular country, athlete, coach or team have put in an inquiry to the judging to create such an investigation? There will always be talk amongst us all as to the judging and where we personally feel a few tenths we're added or denied to our favorite athletes or teams but overall I think all the elite judges do their best to judge well on the spot. I find it odd that this judge was questioned over what I am assuming was a questionable few tenths when there was such a debacle over the bars finals. Why we're those judges not questioned? Even if they find those judges did nothing wrong I cannot believe they wouldn't have also investigated them as well since those scores were such an anomaly in this sport. I feel badly that one judge was singled out. Was it due to a major deviance in score versus the other judges on beam that signaled the inquiry?

      -B

      Delete
    3. I don't really know - I think that the FIG should publish the proceedings of these hearings to make things transparent. I assume there was a variance between her marks for the gymnasts named, and the marks of other judges. She didn't judge again in the comp. I kind of wonder more why she was cleared?

      Delete
  3. I did not know that judges could be involved in marking athlets of their own countries. That shouldn't happen in the first place.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In that case there would be no one who could judge these competitions - all the judges come from somewhere 😀. And then there are the Tech Committees who draft the Codes of Points - they can all skew things if they want to. The illusion of bias free, objective marking can't be maintained for long if you think about it.

      Delete
    2. I hope more details will be published as put like this it can seem like a specific grudge with the Russian panel in light of the doping scandal

      Delete
    3. This all took place well before the doping scandal was publicly known about. I don't think it is a grudge, but it does appear to have been poorly managed. Hopefully, as you say, the FIG will release more details.

      Delete
    4. I think the weird thing is that the Russians decided to publicize this. These investigations happen every year, but the FIG never names those under investigation (nor specifies the event or phase of the competition the investigated were judging). To my knowledge the FIG doesn't even publicly name the judges who are found guilty! It always leaves the fans to speculate about which events might be under scrutiny, like I know for the 2014 worlds a large number of men's judges were investigated and many people thought it was related to the Chinese men's very close, controversial win over Japan. But all we can do is speculate because FIG never makes it public - it's possible some of the judges in the UB final were investigated, we just wouldn't hear their own federations publicize it!

      I get that she was cleared of the allegations, but it's still an odd decision IMO. Cultural difference?

      Delete
    5. Also, to the OP, the only rule is that you are not allowed to judge an event final if a gymnast from your own country is competing. Otherwise, you're good. It's interesting that Ulyankina could potentially end up judging two of her own personal gymnasts in Rio if Paseka and Tutkhalyan both make the team! Although I guess we never see her out on the floor with them anyway.

      Delete
    6. I can only assume that for some reason the news of Vera's suspension leaked and she felt she wanted to clear her name. More of a local than a cultural thing, then my blog goes and translates it into English!
      I do think more transparency in these matters would help the FIG demonstrate the fairness of its proceedings - otherwise with all thatched happening in the wider world of sport it might be left open to nuance and innuendo.

      Delete
  4. http://www.fig-gymnastics.com/site/figNews/view?id=1593

    Well this is interesting....maybe the FIG has decided to start being more transparent? I can't remember them having ever named specific judges who were sanctioned before!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tatyana Nabiyeva on work and love in China

Some highlights from a long interview with 2010 World champion Tatyana Nabiyeva.  Source: Russian team page on VK.com.  Translation - Google translate A big interview with Tatyana Nabieva about the peculiarities of work and life in China, the bright years of her sports career, a little about modern gymnastics and about love. On the Nabiyeva flight — At the same championship, you presented a new element on the bars, which was later added to the rules with your last name (flying over the top bar with a straight body, difficulty group F. — Sport24). How did you come up with the idea to try something new? — Actually, it happened spontaneously, I think. We worked with Vera Iosifovna [Kiryashova] on the purity of the elements on the bars, sometimes I didn’t fly all the way to the Shaposhnikova element. Once I didn’t fly all the way to the bars either and stood on my feet between the bars, bending my legs in flight for safety. Then Vera Iosifovna said that this was a different eleme...

Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics

Svetlana Boginskaya, 15 years old, with her medals from the Seoul Olympics Nico translates the latest interview with gymnastics legend Svetlana Boginskaya, during a recent visit to her home country of Belarus. Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics, so now I ask for forgiveness from everyone who came in contact with me. The National Olympic Committee of Belarus held a press conference with three-time Olympic Champion in artistic gymnastics, Svetlana Boginskaya. The meeting was devoted to the 25th anniversary of the Olympic Games in Seoul. In South Korea the Belarussian won two gold medals in the team competition and vault. As a gift to the Olympic Hall of fame, the famous gymnast, now living in the United States, donated one of her trophies that she won at the 1990 European Championships and a pennant for Best Female Athlete of the USSR in 1989. How happy we were when we could share with such stars as Boginskaya, Scherbo, and Ivankov,...

Alexander Alexandrov in his own words 1 - A Difficult Decision

Alexander Alexandrov with his daughter, Isa, at the statue of Christ the Redeemer, Rio.  (c) Alexander Alexandrov Russian coach Alexander Alexandrov has been prominent in the sport since 1983, when he came to the public eye as coach of the brilliant Dmitri Bilozerchev.  He has over thirty years’ experience of coaching World and Olympic Champions both in the country of his birth and in his adopted home, Houston, USA.  In his most recent position as Head Coach of the national women's artistic gymnastics (WAG) team for Russia, he quite simply resurrected his country’s gymnastics programme, re-establishing his team at the very top of the sport.  Prior to Alexandrov’s appointment, at the 2008 Olympics, Russian WAG had walked away empty handed, without medals.  At last year’s London Olympics, artistic gymnastics was one of Russia’s most successful sports.  Alexandrov’s Russia won the most gymnastics medals of any country competing, and his athlete Al...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more