Skip to main content

Viktoria wasn't the only one who was surprised - commentators' reactions to 2011 Worlds

Viktoria Komova accepts her silver medal all around at the Tokyo World Championships in 2011


The 2011 Worlds are well over now. The gold medals won in Tokyo and, the following year, in London, put America in prime position as we approach the Antwerp World Championships this autumn. They are reigning World and Olympic champions in both team and all around. Only the all around title will be contested in September, so America will inevitably remain team champions until 2014. Event finals are, relatively, small fry.

Let's not forget, however, that this seemingly dominant position stems from two highly controversial all around competitions. In both cases, Komova versus Wieber and Komova versus Douglas, the result could have gone either way; reverse the positions, and world rankings in WAG might look a little more balanced.

The judgements made are not black and white. They cannot be denied or affirmed by a simple one sentence assertion, and they bear continued discussion if we are not to lose sight of the fundamental questions about the codification and judging of gymnastics, how it can influence the gymnastics routines we see top gymnasts performing, and the quality of the gymnastics we see across the ranks.  Remember, although the title of Olympic champion went to Douglas, the reference judges' scores made Komova the winner. The Code, and the judges, could not find a consensus of who was the best gymnast at this major competition. 

Debating and elaborating opinion forces people to articulate what is difficult to express, and hence to try to find what has become lost in the current Code.  Sometimes, however, reactions go beyond words.  Now, this video captures the feelings of many observers regarding the outcome of the women's all around in Tokyo 2011.  It's international, multilingual and universally comprehensible - a gasp of surprise, shock and dismay is the same in any language.



You can also read a reflection on this judgement, and a full transcript of the BBC commentary here.

Comments

  1. I would have preferred, if Vika would have won. However, I am over it because both competitions were close and could have gone either way. That does leave room to debate who should have won, but it makes the winner worthy enough. Honestly, I wasn't impressed by either Vika or Jordyn's AA performance. They both performed much better in qualifications and in Wieber's case team finals as well. Wieber had the form break on bars and stepped out of bounds on floor. Komova scraped the bar when coming down from her layout jaeger, was shaky on beam, dropped out of spins on floor, and had some low landings. I would say that Wieber's floor score was a little high though. When I first watched this competition, I was shocked that Komova lost as well, but I didn't know much about gymnastics then and why Komova was deducted.

    At the Olympics, Douglas had a more consistent performance, but you could argue with the scoring. Vika stepped off the mat on her amanar, which ultimately was the deciding factor. IMO all of the top 4 were over scored at some point in the AA competition. Douglas was over scored by about 2 tenths each on bars, beam, and vault. Vika was over scored on vault and beam by 1-2 tenths, but underscored on floor by 2-3 tenths. Aliya was a little over scored on beam IMO. Raisman was over marked the most by the judges IMO. There is no way her amanar deserved a 15.9. She had tucked knees, separated legs, and a big step on the landing. Aly was also a little over marked on bars as well. Still, it could have gone to either Vika or Gabby. The reference judges thought Vika and the actual judges thought Gabby. There is nothing you can do about it.

    I wouldn't make the reference judges the most reliable. They seemed to have favorites of their own. I believe they enjoyed the more lean, graceful body type. They really favored the Russians, Kyla Ross, and McKayla Maroney, over most of the others. For example, they thought McKayla should have won vault finals even with the fall. They also thought that Ross should have made beam finals over Raisman (I agree though). Ranking Komova over Douglas and Mustafina over Raisman isn't much evidence of having favorites because many thought these should be the final results. But, making Maroney the winner with a fall is evidence IMO.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Whether Viktoria should have won Worlds or not I think it's a bit presumptuous to assume that all of these gymnastic commentators agreed that Vika should have won. They seem more surprised at Vika's score and the 0.033 difference between Wieber and Komova.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What makes you say that Andy? There is a transcript of the English language commentary that specifically references surprise at the outcome of the competition - are you able to translate the other comments or to say why you think this?
      Not that TV commentators are the be all and end all - I just think they gave interesting gut reactions to what was the deciding mark.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Who really won the WAG All Around?

You will find a link to the FIG's newly published book of results at the Olympic Games here .  This year, they have broken down the judge's execution scores so you can see exactly how each judge evaluated the gymnasts' performances.  It makes for interesting reading - if only I had more time to analyse each judge's marking.  A skim reading already highlights multiple inconsistencies in individual judges' marks and makes you wonder why they bother with the jury at all. I have taken the time to look at the reference judges' scores for the top four in the women's all around.  The FIG explains here what their role is, and how they are selected.  I even used my calculator, which is a risky thing in my hands.  My, how I wish we could have seen a similar document for the Tokyo World Championships. I wonder if anyone can explain how, if the FIG's Code of Points is so objective and fair, it is possible to come up with two different results using two differ...

Simone and the others - results and reflections

In the end, it was as predicted : Simone and the others, with Simone's teammate, Alexandra Raisman, providing the back up.  I do not need to point out that, by definition, the Americans are scoring significantly higher marks than the rest of the field.  Congratulations to them! Aliya Mustafina finished in third place.  The 2012 bronze medalist led the competition after vault and uneven bars, but had a very nervous outing on beam that might have taken a less experienced gymnast out of the medals.  A bravura performance on floor brought Aliya back though to confirm her third place all around.  From her senior debut in 2010 to today, Mustafina has continuously set high standards of grace.    It is the first time since 2000 that a gymnast (Amanar) has medalled in the all around at two consecutive Olympics, and  if Aliya can medal on Saturday's uneven bars final, she will once again be Russia's biggest medal winner of the women's gymnastics.  Russ...

Andrei Rodionenko explains Russia's performance at Worlds - Lupitatranslates

Rodionenko with European Champion David Belyavski  Courtesy RGF/Elena Mikhailova This is the interview that many people on the internet have already commented on, regarding Andrei Rodionenko's alleged racism.  The original, Russian language version, appears on VTB Bank's website (VTB are sponsors of Russian gymnastics).  It takes cleverer people than me to decide what is racism, what is deliberately perjorative, and what is inferred in an interviewer's question.  For now, I will not comment on this, therefore, but I would ask you to read Lupita's translation carefully before you form your own opinion.   I am providing some links below which might help you to decide where you stand. Definition of racism Definition of sexism BBC Sport article by Matthew Syed : Is it wrong to note that 100m winners are always black?            Updated 24/10 CSKA Moscow: UEFA opens racist chants case         ...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more