Skip to main content

Will the real Aliya Mustafina please step forward?

Image
By
Not a fake profile ... Aliya's unofficial fanpage has over 50,000 followers

Have you seen the film Spartacus, the bit where the Romans try to get Spartacus to give himself up, but fail because there are so many people who claim to be him?

The gymnastics online community is getting a little bit like that ... I did some counting this morning on Facebook, having come across yet another online profile of a gymnast that claimed to be 'real' yet obviously wasn't :-)

22 online profiles of Aliya Mustafina
29 of Viktoria Komova

Some of these are athlete pages that present news of the gymnast's progress, but many are simply fake identities that make use of personal photographs found elsewhere on the internet to develop whole new narratives of the gymnast's life.  I love my regular Gin O'Clock updates of HRH the Queen's daily life as much as the next person, but these profiles try to pretend to be the real Aliya or Vika, without the embellishment of humour or even a courtesy acknowledgement of the sources used.  I don't think any harm is meant ... but I would feel violated if somebody else grabbed my private pictures and began to pretend they were an online version of me ...

Interestingly, though I thought there might be similar counts for other gymnasts, the vast majority of the 'fakes' seems to be on these two.  Perhaps the English language speaking gymnasts have more opportunity to keep their identities private. I also think that these two - highly professional sports stars - deserve more official help in sensitively policing and promoting their online social media presence.
Labels:

Comments

  1. lilianamichelena2 June 2013 at 17:14

    It actually surprises me that the RGF hasn't done anything yet (especially after what happened with their ex-official websites last year). They need to have an american style social media approach (sharing a lot, media-trained everything); I understand both girls love their privacy and that's cool. But it's PR, and even if they feel like both of them deserve to be protected and they are not going to manage their official social accounts, they should, at least hire a CM.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. lilianamichelena4 June 2013 at 05:55

      Whoops, I meant they DON'T need and american style social media approach.

      Delete
  2. cpt.Hook3 June 2013 at 17:50

    I hope Russians will never adopt American social media approach. To watch American interviews is the most boring and useless thing ever. If you saw one, you saw them all. "it was great, it was fun, blah blah blah "

    ReplyDelete
  3. Unknown4 June 2013 at 04:07

    Well not all of them are fake, the ones that have the name of the gymnast and then the words online were "official" the creator had direct contact with the gymnasts, I know because pavlova has a profile on a certain page, and she and him talked a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Unknown19 June 2013 at 16:35

    I agree completely, but you will find a lot of these so-called fake as friends in other profiles that claim to be real

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous30 July 2013 at 22:19

    As the person who started years ago the unofficial Aliya fb page, I must point out that we neeever ever pretended to be her, we even suggested fans not to add the fake Aliyas and despite of the fact that I speak russian, I prefer to leave the real Aliya alone instead of trying to befriend her and try to look oh-so-cool-and-important in the eyes of the gymnastics online community. As a matter of fact, me and Vitor don't want Aliya fans to add us on facebook so we rarely reveal our identity!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Queen Elizabeth31 July 2013 at 08:00

    I hope the article doesn't read as though I am attacking fan pages some of which of course can be informative and entertaining.

    All I am really saying is that given the number of fake identities on Facebook you would think somebody - most obviously the Federation, but I may be mistaken - would take up some positive PR and identity protection on behalf of these young girls.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Who needs difficulty? Portraits of a young gymnast - Ivan Stretovich

By
These pictures of young Ivan Stretovich, taken by Elena Mikhailova at last week's European Gymnastics Championships, are available in a gallery at the Russian Gymnastics Federation website.  I wanted to share a sequence of them with you. Stretovich turns 16 in October, and comes from Novosibirsk in Siberia, where he is coached at the Dynamo club by B Konvissar.  This young gymnast emerged at April's Russian Championships, where he took gold or silver medals in every event final except for vault.  In Montpelier, he contributed to the Russian team's silver medal. But pictures speak louder than words, and medals aren't all that matters.  Stretovich's start values (in qualifying 5 (F), 5.1 (PH), 4.8 (SR), 5.4 (V), 5.1 (PB) and 4.9 (HB) leave some room for development, but the special quality of his work is even rarer than a double twisting double back somersault.  That quality is the ability to elevate the simple to a pitch of perfection, and to make the diff...
5 comments
Read more

Nelli Kim - 'Russian gymnastics has closed in on itself' - Lupita translates

By
Lupita has translated this ITAR-TASS interview with Nelli Kim.  It's controversial, to say the least. Ed's note : much of the initial response to this interview - both here and in the wider gymternet -  has focussed on the detail of Kim's words and especially her comments about Viktoria Komova, and smiling.  But I think these have to be taken in context, and not too literally. Don't forget that just a day ago Andrei Rodionenko complained bitterly about the judging in Antwerp, calling Kim's behaviour 'aggressive'. Kim is responding to this here, and to the wider current context of Russian gymnastics.  What she is essentially saying to the Russian coach is 'get your own house in order, produce confident, disciplined, well trained gymnasts - stop complaining, do your job, and I will do mine.'   She goes about saying this in a somewhat long winded way and says some things along the way that seem contradictory, unfair, inappropriate even for th...
30 comments
Read more

Decoding Dmitri Andreev’s Coaching Values.

By
When a new head coach takes on one of the most influential roles in artistic gymnastics, it is natural to ask what values and principles guide their leadership. In Dmitri Andreev’s case, most of what we know comes not from personal essays or political statements, but from interviews, press conferences, and official announcements related to his work in the sport.   Understanding his values means paying attention to how he talks about athletes, coaching, leadership, and the future of Russian gymnastics. Several consistent themes emerge from his public comments. Collective Effort Over Individual Glory Andreev regularly presents gymnastics as a collective endeavour rather than a platform for individual achievement. When discussing his appointment as head coach, he emphasised the importance of bringing together athletes, coaches, and support staff to work towards shared goals. He also described leadership in terms of responsibility rather than authority. This suggests a value system cen...
Post a Comment
Read more

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more