Skip to main content

Success factors of Soviet gymnastics .... success factors of Russian gymnastics?

The success of the Soviet Union women was not founded on reliability. Most of their World and European Champions suffered errors en route to their notable victories. Yurchenko was notorious for her unpredictability pre-1982; Shushunova fell twice on bars in qualifications during the 1985 World Championships; Davydova’s gold at the Moscow Olympics was a surprise, given her error rate at previous competitions. Often, it was the most beautiful Soviets who were the least competitive: Ilienko and Shaposhnikova were stunningly erratic. Behind them stood a whole army of astonishing but competitively inept aspiring World Champions, many of them well known but who never made World Champion teams: Groshkova, Priakhina, Shkoda, Mysnik.

The entire history of Soviet gymnastics is littered with brilliant, but unpredictable startlets. Their teams were no less likely to win because of it. We were no less in their awe because of it. A certain degree of unreliability – risk - was expected if the gymnasts were to deliver the pace of technical and artistic progress necessary to keep more than one or two steps ahead of the rest of the world. Teams were relatively unbothered by the occasional error, simply because they recognised it as part of the game.

My perspective on this probably goes against the grain of contemporary thinking on gymnastics success, partly because of changes in competition format, partly because of the predominance of the Romanian team around the mid to late 1990s, who established the ideal of gymnastics as reliable, error-free performance. And while the Romanians’ reliability may have earned them plenty of gold medals, and respect from fellow competitors, it did nothing to add to the interest of gymnastics. I’ll never forget the horror of watching Gogean win the 1997 World Beam Championships with a routine that included one simple acrobatic element.

Reliability does not go hand in hand with brilliance, risk, originality and virtuosity. Risk has a natural, synergistic link with unreliability. Originality and virtuosity bring with them a downside of risk. The upside of risk is that it takes your competitors by surprise, and leaves them in awe – how was that possible!! How can we possibly compete with that?!

What made the Soviets so great? Not reliability. Nor a wise reading of the Code. None of these, but some of the following, in varying degrees. Strength in depth. The understanding that gymnastics is a team, not individual sport. Courage. Creativity and imagination. A cultural heritage of ballet training that granted the vocabulary by which to understand and pass down beautiful, original movement from generation to generation. A concentration of talent.

To command leadership of this sport – as distinct from merely winning medals - you must take risks. This is as true today as it was in the 1980s, and I believe it is a principle that the Russians will adopt as they pursue their plan to re-establish themselves at the top of the gymnastics tree, not just till 2012, but beyond. Expect some bumps and bruises, shocks and surprises as we roll onwards into the gymnastics horizon …

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

USSR is a mighty sports power!

Once upon a time sportsmen were heros and role models, a shining moral example for all of society as to the values of a strong work ethic and a healthy body. USSR is a might sports power!  B. Reshetnikov, 1962  Picture courtesy of A Soviet Poster a Day I love these Soviet era posters and the way they capture the spirit of the time, something special about the purity of the collective sporting effort.  Of course today, sport is about different things.  The political and behavioural symbolic value of sport has been replaced by sport as a commodity.  Sports stars exist as brand heroes in our shopping centres and glossy magazines, the sometimes lurid details of their everyday lives trumpeted on the pages of such magazines as Hello! and the gossip pages of the internet. Compare photographs of Olympians Svetlana Khorkina (1996, 2000 and 2004) and Ludmilla Tourischeva (1972, 1976): Khorkina is in all her glamour shot, sexually charged splendour; Svetlana Khorkina, undated Tou

UPDATE 23/9 - Russian WAG team for Nanning confirmed

Daria Spiridonova will compete at her first World Championships this autumn.  Picture : RGF Natalia Kalugina has confirmed the Russian team for Nanning : Aliya Mustafina, Maria Kharenkova, Tatiana Nabieva,Ekaterina Kramarenko, Alla Sosnitskaya, Daria Spiridonova.  Reserve : Polina Fyodorova Here is a paraphrased translation of a comment by Natalia Kalugina on her Facebook page : 'Aliya has confidence in competition and she is, kind of, a coach to this team.  In Europe she succeeded in this role and she has told the coaches that she even liked it. The main fighting force will be Kharenkova, Sosnitskaya and Spiridonova.  Accordingly, the strongest apparatus will be beam (Marina Bulashenko With God!).  The Chinese women, of course, have been known to win that apparatus, but if one falls, they all fall.   Alla Sosnitskaya could compete in the vault final, and - in theory - on the floor. On bars, of course, Russia will probably lose to the Chinese women, but they should be able to hold

Russian Nationals 2024 : Part 2 WAG Team Finals and Individual Qualifiers

Injury was a main concern for the Russian women at this competition.  Of the Olympians, only Gerasimova competed at full strength.  Both Listunova and Melnikova were suffering with pain; you could see this on their faces and in their movement, by the end of the day's competition.  For Listunova, foot and back pain were problems, while Melnikova had severe achilles pain.  Melnikova is booked in for an MRI as soon as she returns to Moscow after a short break in Sochi, where she is staying with David Belyavski and his family.   Slava Urazova didn't make the competition at all after injuring her knee in training.  Ilyankova has retired.  Both Diana Kustova and Alena Glotova are still recovering from chest infections and Kustova did not compete at all.  Up and coming gymnasts worth watching include Lyudmilla Roschina, Leila Vasileeva (a favourite of mine) and Maria Agafanova.  The standard of execution was generally good, although there were lots of mistakes, especially on beam.  On

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more