Skip to main content

Weren't we mesmerised by the promise of gold? Abuse in gymnastics I

Iā€™ve questioned myself time and again about gymnastics, ever since the ā€˜Me Tooā€™ messages began appearing on my Twitter feed.  Are we, fans, culpable of supporting a sport which is inherently brutal?  Have we elevated our sport because of the brutality involved in making it to the top?  What is it about gymnastics that has somehow led to the tacit acceptance of abuse as a way of life?

Only a few years ago Dominique Moceanu published her book, calling out her parents and her coaches, the Karolyis, as abusive.  Did we stop and listen?  No.  We labelled Dominique an ā€˜attention seekerā€™.  

And what about ā€˜Little Girls in Pretty Boxesā€™?  Did we rush to support the injured parties?  Insist on a sports-wide review of coaching practice?  No.  There was a media storm and lots of huffs and puffs, but we never got round to blowing the house down.  

At the end of the day, werenā€™t we mesmerised by the promise of gold?

Abuse has been hiding in plain view for decades, not just in gymnastics but in other areas of high performance including sports, ballet, circus, theatre.  It is a global, long-standing problem that exists wherever young people rely on adults for instruction and support, and where high performance is the objective.

How do we moderate welfare and performance?  What is our priority?

Changing the age at which gymnasts can begin competing has been suggested, but legislation or regulation has limited results in a global context.  The FIG can make rules but national culture or governance can always find ways to sidestep or subvert the rules.  Countries are the big villains.  Collective culture muddies the waters and confuses priorities.  National administrations cover up, encourage malpractice, force athletes and coaches to break rules.  Collectively, we feel absolved of responsibility and cheer top performances, elevating othersā€™ personal sacrifices to a kind of religion that we worship.  We want to see the tiny underdog win, and so much the better if she shares our nationality.  Who cares how a gymnast wins, as long as she fights for gold?

We still have to agree what the problem is.  There is no internationally agreed definition of abuse.  Abuse is relative.  Levels of domestic violence in Russia are unknown.  People, generally, donā€™t talk about it.  In China, many people believe that hardship in childhood is essential to turn out responsible, strong adults.  

Abuse is a time-bound concept.  What was acceptable practice in the classroom, family or gym twenty years ago is not the same today.    Society has taken steps forward, at different paces in different countries.   

Even in the field of human rights and child rights ā€“ which you would consider fundamental ā€“ there is no internationally enforceable law.  Countries opt into signing agreements and can be shamed into acting to reduce human right infringements.  But what sanctions are available to enforce respect of international law?  Why should sport be any different?

Social media gave a voice to individuals and enabled the ā€˜Me Tooā€™ generation and the current discussion around how we can protect athletes.  So far, however, that discussion is only taking place if you can speak English.  If we want global solutions to global problems, we need to talk globally, and everyone has to be involved.  But not everyone agrees that there is a problem to talk about.

 Perhaps the most powerful tool we have to combate abuse in sports is to continue to talk about it and to break down national cultural barriers.  To come to an understanding.  No single rule change will create a globally safe sport environment until we can all agree what sport means, why it is important and how we decide where strict training finishes and abuse begins.  No matter the age of the athlete, this is the Big Question.   

Looked at another way, sport can provide a channel to work out our collective global attitude towards the rights of others.  Gymnastics' problems do not exist in isolation but are a manifestation of our society.


Elizabeth Booth, 22nd November 2020

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ā€˜My daughter likes gymnastics. For us, this is the big successā€™. Aliya Mustafina talks to Match TV

Via VK.com.  Google translate A big interview with Aliya Mustafina was published on MATCH!. We provide a small excerpt below, and the full version is available on the website at the link below  ā“ Aliya, you are now the head coach of the junior artistic gymnastics team. What does your typical day look like? šŸ’œ My current life is similar to what it was when I was competing. In the morning, I have breakfast and go to work by 9:00, we train for four hours, have lunch, rest and train for another three hours. During the training camp, the athletes live at the base. They live and train on the same territory. ā“ Do you manage the gymnasts' personal trainers or do you evenly distribute the responsibilities? šŸ’œ We work in contact with the personal trainers, I listen to their opinions. For example, if the trainer believes that their athlete needs to be given a little rest or do fewer repetitions of a particular exercise, we do so. ā“ Describe the current generation of children. Do they nee...

Simone and the others - results and reflections

In the end, it was as predicted : Simone and the others, with Simone's teammate, Alexandra Raisman, providing the back up.  I do not need to point out that, by definition, the Americans are scoring significantly higher marks than the rest of the field.  Congratulations to them! Aliya Mustafina finished in third place.  The 2012 bronze medalist led the competition after vault and uneven bars, but had a very nervous outing on beam that might have taken a less experienced gymnast out of the medals.  A bravura performance on floor brought Aliya back though to confirm her third place all around.  From her senior debut in 2010 to today, Mustafina has continuously set high standards of grace.    It is the first time since 2000 that a gymnast (Amanar) has medalled in the all around at two consecutive Olympics, and  if Aliya can medal on Saturday's uneven bars final, she will once again be Russia's biggest medal winner of the women's gymnastics.  Russ...