Skip to main content

The Produnova vault, Dipa Karmakar and the Commonwealth Games

  Elena Produnova - one of the most beautiful and powerful gymnasts ever


Ahead of today's Commonwealth Games WAG vault final, where India's Dipa Karmakar will attempt her handspring double front vault, I just wanted to take the opportunity to remind people that it IS possible to perform this risky skill safely and well.


http://youtu.be/nQuIQ9s3ddM


Produnova cowboys this attempt but it is high, flighty and well landed.  She was ahead of her time, launching into space off an old-style vaulting horse that did not offer the benefits of the new vaulting table.


Dipa Karmakar (see video below) has managed to qualify to event finals at the Commonwealth Games as a consequence of a difficult vault performed very poorly.  


http://youtu.be/yE8v5-jlOoY


The second vault scored 14.4 with an E score of 7.4.  The difficulty value of the Produnova is 7 - almost a mark higher than the Amanar vault that is otherwise considered to be the acme of women's vaulting achievement.  Karmakar barely gets her feet on the ground first - and certainly doesn't have enough control to stop the forward rotation as she lands.


I wonder if she will do any better today?


Some people will call for the vault to be banned as unsafe, but I don't think that is the answer when we have evidence that it is possible to do it well.  The problem is that gymnasts are encouraged to risk life and limb because they can achieve excessive scores with very poor technique.  The judging just doesn't penalise fully for an unsafe attempt.


Deduct, judges, deduct.

Comments

  1. A more general point on e scores from watching the AA final the other day; I think judges need to be given more freedom with e score deductions, specifically deductions for poor form. For example, a wobble or step can be .1, .3 or .5 depending on the size of the error, but form deductions are much more limited. A cowboyed tuck is only ever .1.
    I think .1 should be for minor knee separation, .3 for knees wider than your shoulders. Similarly, knee bends should be looked at based on how bent (the angle) the knee is. Slightly soft knees should not be the same as something approaching a tuck shape. They are both poor form, but a gymnast who can only perform a score by chucking it and flailing around in the air should be punished more harshly that a gymnast who has not kept correct tension through the legs.
    I hate poor form, which I think should actually be easier for gymnasts to avoid than a bounce on landing, given how springy floors are now.

    After that semi rant, I actually enjoyed a lot of the work of the Malaysian gymnast in the AA final. It was by no means difficult, but she generally executed well, and she had a nice style and grace in her work.

    On the vaulting issues; I think that if a gymnast if performing something that is dangerous and that they have no control over (so many attempts at the Prudunova spring to mind) their coach should face sanction. This would stop coaches pushing their athletes to throw skills that they are ill equipped to perform.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Having watched both the men and the women's vault finals, I think the code needs to adjusted to value form and execution more. Vault finals are becoming more and more of a messy chuck and hope affair, and even if nobody gets injured, it's still not very pleasant to watch.

    Elizabeth Black performed two generally well executed vaults with stuck landings where she wasn't bent in half. Claudia Fragapane had greater difficulty, but her form is terrible and she barely holds her straight shape in her second vault.

    I was actually pleasantly surprised by the Indian gymnast's Prudunova, but unless she's consistently able to do it I think it's still dangerous.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think if anyone in this quad could land this vault perfectly it would be Mustafina. She is one of few performing perfectly vertical high double front on floor. I think it will be possibly easier for her than others to stick it.

    Alfi

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Who really won the WAG All Around?

You will find a link to the FIG's newly published book of results at the Olympic Games here .  This year, they have broken down the judge's execution scores so you can see exactly how each judge evaluated the gymnasts' performances.  It makes for interesting reading - if only I had more time to analyse each judge's marking.  A skim reading already highlights multiple inconsistencies in individual judges' marks and makes you wonder why they bother with the jury at all. I have taken the time to look at the reference judges' scores for the top four in the women's all around.  The FIG explains here what their role is, and how they are selected.  I even used my calculator, which is a risky thing in my hands.  My, how I wish we could have seen a similar document for the Tokyo World Championships. I wonder if anyone can explain how, if the FIG's Code of Points is so objective and fair, it is possible to come up with two different results using two differ...

Simone and the others - results and reflections

In the end, it was as predicted : Simone and the others, with Simone's teammate, Alexandra Raisman, providing the back up.  I do not need to point out that, by definition, the Americans are scoring significantly higher marks than the rest of the field.  Congratulations to them! Aliya Mustafina finished in third place.  The 2012 bronze medalist led the competition after vault and uneven bars, but had a very nervous outing on beam that might have taken a less experienced gymnast out of the medals.  A bravura performance on floor brought Aliya back though to confirm her third place all around.  From her senior debut in 2010 to today, Mustafina has continuously set high standards of grace.    It is the first time since 2000 that a gymnast (Amanar) has medalled in the all around at two consecutive Olympics, and  if Aliya can medal on Saturday's uneven bars final, she will once again be Russia's biggest medal winner of the women's gymnastics.  Russ...

Aliya Mustafina - 'each medal is very special'

'I'm very happy that everything turned out well today  ... Each medal is very special.  The UK team made mistakes, so there was a wide margin [of victory]... But naturally, [what I did] is not enough for the Olympics.  I prepared well for beam and bars but I am not ready for floor, I stepped up to help the team. ... To be honest, I did not look at the scores [when asked how the team reacted to the 6.5 gap before the final apparatus].  Gelya (Melnikova) is a good girl, she did everything and did not falter ... Seda fell on quite a complex element.  There is more work to do, but everything else went well.' [About a protest taken by the coaches on her beam score]. 'I am used to my protests being rejected, everything is normal!' Via vk.com I n other news , the UEG has confirmed that Spiridonova will replace Melnikova in tomorrow's bars final. No reason is given, but it is generally considered that Dasha has a better chance of gold.  This decision also means tha...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more