Skip to main content

Can the Russian women win in Rotterdam?

This morning, I wanted to reflect on the present, and the near future. Only 9 days to go till the World Championships in Rotterdam (well, podium training begins in 9 days). Can the Russian women win? What is the significance of this competition to them? Is it possible to predict the outcome of a competition? Does it matter who takes the medals?

What is ‘winning’, anyway? We all know that medals will be distributed in team, all-around, and event finals, and that huge emotional significance is attached to world titles. And not just for the competitors - I personally will cry buckets if Russia win any kind of gold. But let’s be pragmatic. Rotterdam is only a step on the way to the London 2012 Olympics, and all the athletes there must tread a precarious psychological pathway between living in the now, and preparing for the future, en route to probably the biggest experience of their lives (which some of them may not make). Rotterdam is merely a battle, not the whole war. And for the Russians, one senses that a greater war exists even than the Olympics: that of shaping the sport.

In Rotterdam, the team competition seems to me to be the biggest ‘fish’ that the Russians might want to try to catch. But I consider this to be an extremely difficult feat, as the competition format of 6-3-3 does not suit their approach to the sport.

Some would say that this comes down to psychological vulnerability and, sure, we have seen brilliant Russian teams fail somewhat in the heat of competition, most notably the 2000 Russian Olympic team. This must have been a massive blow to the self-belief of those gymnasts and I believe it infected the whole of the Russian system, contributing to the sharp decline we saw in the years between Sydney and Beijing.

Beyond this, however, I do not believe that there is anything that makes Russian gymnasts more intrinsically vulnerable psychologically than any others. We all remember the impression of invincibility that the Soviet women had, and compare Russian teams with them, but forget that Soviet success was forged on the basis of strength in depth, with gymnasts drawn from 15 nations. And critically, the team competition format in those days of 6-6-5 allowed for a balancing out of individual disasters. Remember Shushunova and Omelianchik’s failures on bars in 1985 and Yurchenko’s fall from the bars in the all around final in the same year?

Yet these gymnasts’ names live on as legends of the sport. Why? Because their gymnastics somehow captured the imagination; they were innovative and took risk: their gymnastics was imbued with balletic charm and expression. Even when they didn’t win the gold medal, they managed to hold the moral and creative leadership of the sport. 6-6-5 was a good format because it supported teams in developing their skills base and in trying out new, risky elements. It meant the sport could progress and change rapidly. As opposed to 6-3-3 which tests nothing more than stolid reliability. And as the Code at least partly dictates the kind of performances we see on the competition podium (Barker-Ruchti, 2009 provides an interesting framework based on the work of Foucault), gymnastics has become, mostly, stolid and reliable.

Which brings me to the main point of this piece – at last!, I hear you say. The Russians, with their liking for risk, are fundamentally at odds with a competition format that favours reliability. It is in their bones to embrace risk. Risk is what the sport needs to make it red-blooded once more, and risk is the only way that any country should merit leadership of the sport, rather than enjoying the fleeting moment of a gold medal. What Russia must do at this competition is show gymnastics that will remind us that Risk, Innovation and Virtuosity are central to their vision of gymnastics.

This will take significant courage, and I believe that a team that includes Afanasyeva, Mustafina, Nabieva and Dementieva has a better than average chance of success. Look at the manner of their performance (especially Afanasyeva), and the astonishing risky new elements they are introducing to the sport (Mustafina, Nabieva and Dementieva). Now, they have to show us their self-belief, and make gymnastics audiences fall silent once more. They do not need the gold medal to achieve this.

If the gold medallists in Rotterdam are anything but Russian, they will probably have a look of fear on their faces – the sound of rapidly overtaking footsteps will most probably be echoing around the stadium.

Reference

Barker-Ruchti, N (2009) 'Ballerinas and Pixies: A Genealogy of the Changing Female Gymnastics Body' International Journal of the History of Sport Vol 26 No 1, pp 45-62

Comments

  1. As a Russophile fan myself, I expect Rotterdam to be the "new beginning" on Russian dominance of the Sport. I agree that if they start dominating podiums, it will be t'he best for gymnastica, it will show the path some other teams should follow. I admit that in any competition I go, only the Russians provoke that "my team" feeling, where I suffer in every skill they do. A team gold for them would put that proud smile and a couple of tears in my face.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

‘We all love her very much’ - Roschina speaks of Mustafina and the need to perfect an Amanar vault

From sport.ru via vk.com.  Google translate  A big interview with Anastasia Loginova from Sport24 with Lyudmila Roshchina following the Strongest Cup, where the gymnast won four out of five gold medals. We quote several fragments, the full version is available on the publication's website, link at the end. ❓ The Strongest Athletes Cup has recently ended. Did you have time to analyze your performances? 💬 I just rewatched the broadcast, looked at my shortcomings. ❓ Did you set a medal plan for this start? 💬 I didn't think about it. Only that I needed to do my program - and then what will happen. ❓ Did you have time to discuss the competition with your coach? 💬 She praised me, said that I was great. She didn't scold me for mistakes on the beam - on the contrary, she supported me. ❓ Can we say that the beam is your weak spot? This is the only final you didn't get to. 💬 Probably yes. I have this apparatus that is a bit unpolished, so to speak. Treacherous. I need to work...

Simone and the others - results and reflections

In the end, it was as predicted : Simone and the others, with Simone's teammate, Alexandra Raisman, providing the back up.  I do not need to point out that, by definition, the Americans are scoring significantly higher marks than the rest of the field.  Congratulations to them! Aliya Mustafina finished in third place.  The 2012 bronze medalist led the competition after vault and uneven bars, but had a very nervous outing on beam that might have taken a less experienced gymnast out of the medals.  A bravura performance on floor brought Aliya back though to confirm her third place all around.  From her senior debut in 2010 to today, Mustafina has continuously set high standards of grace.    It is the first time since 2000 that a gymnast (Amanar) has medalled in the all around at two consecutive Olympics, and  if Aliya can medal on Saturday's uneven bars final, she will once again be Russia's biggest medal winner of the women's gymnastics.  Russ...

AA Champion Liudmilla Roschina targets Olympic gold

  Liudmilla is the first gymnast of the new generation to win AA in the most important international competition in Russia.  The Krasnodar born gymnast was at one time said to be the favourite of head coach of the junior team, Aliya Mustafina.   Source: gymnastics group on VK.com.  Google translate Lyudmila Roshchina shone at the "Strongest Athletes Cup" in artistic gymnastics in Moscow.  🔝 The 17-year-old gymnast became the absolute champion in the all-around and in individual disciplines, winning the vault, parallel bars and floor exercises!  "I am very pleased. There were small mistakes, but they did not prevent me from showing a decent result. I liked the atmosphere of the competition, the full stands helped when I went out on the apparatus. I love all the apparatus, but especially the parallel bars. And, of course, it was interesting to test myself against foreign rivals. In September, the Russian Championship will be held, I want to perform there at ...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more