Skip to main content

Rae Meadows - Winterland - a novel Review

May I recommend this book to you.  


Anya is a young girl living in the dark, cold climate of Norilsk, Siberia.  The pollution makes it difficult for people to live healthy, happy lives and her family is riven by illlness and hardship and in particular the disappearance of her mother.


Anya is a talented gymnast and she is ‘adopted’ by the state system.  Her coach, Anatoly, is brusque and unforgiving.  He recognises the same ambition in Anya as he has for himself, and propels her through years of relentless training to the very top of the sport, a gold medal at the 1980 Olympics.  


There is more to the book than that, though; the cultural and political environment of the Soviet Union is clearly portrayed from the point of view of an ordinary citizen.  The harsh conditions for workers in Norilsk, the queues and the poverty, are well known but the book sensitively reveals the lack of options and freedoms that made life so tough.  Anya’s monthly stipend as a national team member made it easier for the family to eat meat.  Her earnings were a matter of survival.  What she did in the gymnasium helped both to feed her family and to promote victory for the Soviet Union.


I’ve always found it hard to articulate what it is about Russia and gymnastics that I find so compelling - the brutality set against highlights of stunning beauty and emotion; the rigid politics, inspired by an ideology of sharing and equality, yet distorted by power and cruelty.  This book manages to capture some of these paradoxes of the Soviet Union and Russia without turning into a moralistic parable.  It uses its sources well and keeps things simple.


Some of the characters in the book (and I think it’s the characters that make it so good) are recognisable from the gymnastics histories: Elena Mukhina primarily.  A creepy doctor can only have been modelled on Larry Nassar.  One area I thought could have been improved upon was the relationships between the gymnasts on the national team at Round Lake - I don’t think the gymnasts were mean to each other.  A little warmth would have added credibility.


A really good book though, take the time to read it if you can, and let us know what you think of it too!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

European Gymnastics votes to allow Russian participation in UEG competitions

The RGF confirms via Telegram.  Angelina Melnikova attended the Congress in Prague and gave a speech. ‘ ✅ The European Gymnastics Congress voted to reinstate Russian athletes' eligibility for competitions under the organization's auspices. This opens access for artistic and rhythmic gymnastics to qualifying tournaments for the 2028 Olympic Games in Los Angeles. In trampoline, athletes can qualify for the Olympics without going through European competitions. 🗳 Delegates from 46 of the 50 countries that are members of European Gymnastics participated in the vote. Twenty-seven countries voted to allow Russian and Belarusian athletes to compete. The Russian delegation was led by Marat Filippov, Vice President of the Russian Olympic Committee and Secretary of the Presidential Council for Physical Culture and Sport.   💬 Oleg Belozerov, President of the Russian Gymnastics Federation, noted the importance of the decision: "We positively evaluate the position taken by European Gy...

Melnikova withdrawn from Bundesliga

  Angelina Melnikova has issued a statement about her participation in the Bundesliga.     The mayor of Chemnitz has withdrawn the gymnast’s invitation to participate in the final.     Angelina’s words: ‘I didn't receive an invitation to the Bundesliga final. Unfortunately, the public attention and political discussions were much greater than the organizers expected. I am grateful to TSV Tittmoning-Chemnitz for the opportunity to participate in the semi-finals and, most importantly, for their respectful and kind attitude. In Germany, I received tremendous support from spectators, athletes, coaches, and referees. A sports arena is a place where athletes meet each other and demonstrate their abilities in their favorite sport. Sport provides the opportunity to showcase the results of their hard work and athletic prowess. Everyone deserves equal opportunities in all areas of life, and every athlete deserves to compete equally in the sports arena and fulfill their dr...

Ksenia Afanasyeva takes retirement

Leading Russian gymnast since 2007, Ksenia Afanasyeva has retired from gymnastics for medical reasons, reports Alexei Fililov from R Sport.   Valentina Rodionenko explained that Ksenia has a serious kidney illness. She is in hospital and will take not just days but weeks to recover. Afanasyeva is not just a brilliant gymnast but also a kind, humourous and intelligent team captain.  Her presence will be missed by both spectators and fellow competitors in Rio. Ksenia's place on the Russian team travelling to Rio on Sunday will be taken by the experienced and well prepared Evgenia Shelgunova. RRG would like to wish Ksenia a full recovery.  Get well soon, Ksenia and we will look forward to hearing about your next steps in your new life. http://m.rsport.ru/artist_gym/20160721/993115276.html

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more