Skip to main content

Russia today and tomorrow: Dementyeva, Shelgunova and Kharenkova take gold in Europe

Image
By
Evgeniya Shelgunova, courtesy of the UEG

Russia's women gymnasts took gold at two different competitions this weekend, showing an interesting level of development across the generations.  Veteran Anna Dementyeva competed with significantly improved form at the Joaquim Blume Memorial, hitting a 14.75 on beam, while at the annual Massilia Cup in Marseille, France, emerging senior (eligible 2013) Evgeniya Shelgunova led her team to first place, taking the all around title for herself.  Youngster Maria Kharenkova added an exclamation mark to the Russians' performances with an emphatic gold in the floor exercise.

The Russian team's performance was enhanced by tiny Viktoria Kuzmina's silver medal on uneven bars.  The team cumulatively took first place on every piece of apparatus but vault, where their fifth place underlines an urgent need to make improvements.  Even the revaluation of the Amanar vault will not overcome such a deficit whilst competing against a relatively weak field.

Golden Maria Kharenkova, having grown quite a lot since her stunning appearances at this spring's European Championships, was quite magnificent on floor with longer limbs emphasising the height and power of her leaps.  She also showed off some new difficulty, with a one and a half twisting somersault replacing the whip in her second tumble run (ending with double tuck), and adding a stag leap to her final tumble of double pike.  The Russians need a good floor worker or two so it is encouraging to see Maria continue to develop in the midst of a growth spurt. 

It would normally be in the Russians' plans to improve Maria's toe point but considering changes to next year's Code (which defines artistry as good tumbling but makes no mention of line, toe point, harmony or rhythm) they may decide it's not worth the time.

Hey ho.  14 year old Maria's work is still more interesting and aesthetic than the Olympic floor champion's by far, demonstrating that artistry can exist alongside great tumbling without compromising, or robbing the sport of its cultural dimension.  Long live Russian choreographers. 



Labels:

Comments

  1. lilianamichelena19 November 2012 at 15:15

    Loved that bitter last part, but I grew a little worried when I watched the videos. Since artistry and good form isn't going to be rewarded anytime soon, do you think Russia is going to finally drop its traditional focus on beauty and aesthetics and, god forbid, let their juniors go all Aly Raisman?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Queen Elizabeth19 November 2012 at 15:24

      :-)
      I really hope not. I don't really think so, as artistry is embedded in their system from the beginning. It is part of their ethos and make up.
      But if it's not going to be rewarded, if gymnasts like Raisman can win Olympic gold medals, where is the incentive to continue?
      It's surely only making their gymnastics more difficult ... and if that difficulty isn't recognised in the marks, why bother? Concentrating on stability is surely more important. The Americans have got away with emphasising this quality at the expense of the aesthetic, so why shouldn't the Russians?

      Delete
    2. Anonymous20 November 2012 at 21:02

      I don't understand why people believed that only gymnasts like Raisman can win when she didn't even got the bronze at Olympic all around. I think performing the Amanar well enough and adding just a little bit of difficulty on floor and beam would do. They don't need to kill the artistic part, remember that there were once powerful gymnasts with great artistry back in the 80's and 90's. Why it can't happen again?

      Delete
  2. M20 November 2012 at 09:12

    It's really great that Anna is doing well and the youngsters are also performing well. I hope they don't neglect the artistry that they are known for; however, you are correct if they don't get recognized for it and others can win without it, there isn't really an incentive to continue it, but I still hope they do.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie27 November 2012 at 10:22

    How did Kharenkova do on beam? She was a spectacular beam worker at Euros.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mustafina on Roschina

By
ROTTERDAM (Netherlands), October 24. /TASS/. Russian gymnast Lyudmila Roshchina, who won silver in the individual all-around at the World Championships, succeeded precisely because she focused on challenging herself rather than competing for medals. This is the assessment of Aliya Mustafina, a coach for the Russian national team and a two-time Olympic champion, who spoke to TASS. "Of course, I wasn't certain that Lyudmila would end up on the podium in the all-around, though I certainly hoped she would," Mustafina said. "The general instruction was not to think about medals or rankings. As they headed from the warm-up area to the competition floor, I told the girls: 'Don't worry about where you place—just focus on challenging yourselves.' And Lyusya managed to do exactly that." "Her mindset played a major role, too; she was in a very positive frame of mind even back in the warm-up area. So, I wouldn't say that winning this silver was an incre...
Post a Comment
Read more

Roschina on Mustafina

By
 Roshchina discusses Mustafina’s role in the Russian national gymnastics team The Olympic champion has been working with the Russian senior national team since the beginning of 2026 and specializes in the balance beam. "Aliya Fargatovna gives us all sorts of advice and handy tips, which is a huge help to us," Roshchina admitted, adding that Mustafina has been her idol since childhood. Mustafina has been working with the Russian senior national team since the beginning of 2026, specializing in the balance beam. Prior to this, she served as the head coach of the women’s junior national team. Roshchina is 18 years old, and the world championships in Rotterdam mark the second high-level competition of her career. At the 2025 World Championships, she finished 11th in the individual all-around. In August, in Zagreb, she became a European champion as part of the Russian team, which competed under the "World Gymnastics" banner.
Post a Comment
Read more

Roschina on her success in Rotterdam

By
  — Let’s sum up the World Championships. How did it go for you? — First of all, it was a great learning experience for me. Overall, the competition went well, though there is still room for improvement. — If someone had told you before the World Championships that you would take second place in the individual all-around, how would you have reacted? — I probably would have been surprised. I’m not even sure what else to say to that. — How difficult was it to be the leader of the women’s team in the absence of Angelina Melnikova? — I tried to encourage the girls, and they encouraged me as well. I think that, overall, we were a good team. But Angelina is still our leader, and I will look up to her. — I spoke with coach Aliya Mustafina, and she mentioned that the competition within the national team will be even tougher next year…  — It’s great to have such strong competition; it gives you something to strive for and an incentive to keep working. — Did you start out in artistic gy...
Post a Comment
Read more

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more