Skip to main content

Is Gymnastics Art?

Just beginning to read an article (Platchias, 2003) from the European Journal of Sport Science entitled Sport is Art. Platchias attempts to identify the common features of art and sport - difficult because both are open concepts. In fact in some ways, art can be said to be delineated by the cultural classes who confer the label of art on certain forms of production and consumption. Think, for example of your local opera house, if you have one, and now consider its status relative to the latest Muse concert.

The distinction between the aesthetic and the artistic is important; natural landscapes, for example, or people, can be aesthetically pleasing without being considered to be works of art. And one of the distinctions between art and sport is that art is considered to be without purpose or end product; it is an act in its own right, partly unconscious of its own artistry. While the end product of sport is more purposive. Sport is unarguably aesthetic, but is it art?

But if art is wholly unpurposive, what about the commercial backgrounds of many artists and authors; how many of the portraits in the National Gallery, for example, were commissioned works of art? Wasn't Michelangelo paid for his efforts in the Sistine Chapel? Doubtless deeper reading of this article and other, related literature will fill in the gaps and render a more complex framework for consideration.

In the meantime, however, about three pages into the article, as is generally my habit, I found my mind wandering, and went to explore Youtube. It didn't take me long before I found this video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_55nfeBj4Q

This is Olga Strazheva's floor exercise from the 1989 World Championships. Set to Stravinsky's Rites of Spring, its choreography is partially derivative of Nijinsky's 1913 choreography, and was composed in its entirety by choreographers of the Bolshoi Ballet. Wasn't it rather timely that Strazheva's extraordinary floor routine showed up on my computer? To me, Strazheva, her coaches and choreographers produced a piece of performance art. Regardless of the fact that it was performed in a sporting arena it integrated art with sport seamlessly. Isn't this proof that sport is art, without all of this talking? Hmm ... I wonder what Judith Mackrell (dance critic for The Guardian) would think?

Does the sporting aspect of this routine, its manner and place of performance, reduce this work of art to a mere confection of art viewed through the lens of sport? After all, the routine consciously exploited an art form, and the work of major artists, with a view to underlining the artistic superiority of the Soviet team at that competition. It was a routine developed to stretch this particular gymnast's expressive and gymnastic capabilities and to provide her with a tool to win medals. The aesthetic in the routine is unconscious; the artistic there to prove a point. So, art, or not art?

Then it occurred to me that if sport were art, someone would need to be in control of the cultural capital, and delineate exactly what was art, and what wasn't. (That is a crass and over-simplified way of putting it, but please bear with me for a year or two while I develop the cultural capital to make this argument more effectively.) I would suggest, therefore, that the Soviet Union occupied the high ground in this respect during the 60s, 70s and 80s. They shaped the sport in the image of ballet and circus (a higher art form in the USSR than the West) and effectively closed the door on alternative interpretations of the sport, which were inferior by comparison. (And thank goodness for that; would you prefer to have watched more floor routines like this one? Although a version of this did take the world title in 1979; I wonder who possessed the cultural capital then?)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yP-8V_hE3F8

Who would have been brave enough to deny the Soviets the cultural leadership of the sport? You wouldn't want to be labelled uncultured, now would you - note the close relationship to the Bolshoi Ballet - are you going to take them on and win? (Although Eberle's coaches and the judges who gave her the win in 1979 didn't seem to mind too much. An anomaly that is difficult to explain perhaps.)

But who are the gatekeepers of the artistic in gymnastics now? Is there a dearth of artistry, or has it merely changed as an art form? Even if artistry has disappeared, does the inherent aesthetic in gymnastics render the sport art?

Reference

Platchias, D (2003) 'Sport is Art' European Journal of Sport Science vol 3 issue 4 pp 1-18

Comment added 8.10.2010

This is a bit of a mangled account based on a rapid reading of an article fragment, and isn’t helped by the lack of secondary references that for some reason are pretty thin on the ground in the body of Platchias’s work. My emphasis on the importance of cultural capital is derived from his mention of members of the art world ‘christening’ works of art (Dickie, 1974, cited by Platchias, 2003) – I have taken this further to identify the idea of cultural capital, for which my source is Pierre Bourdieu.

The thought that this leaves hanging in my brain is whether there is some equivalent concept to ‘cultural capital’ in sports and whether the transference of this capital influences the shape of the sport. What political influences held sway, for example, during the 1979 World Championships? This was admittedly a low point in Soviet gymnastics history when they lost the world team title to Romania, and the world floor title went to the unfortunate Emilia Eberle. Can this be interpreted as a temporary sway in the ownership of the sporting cultural capital? What were the underlying cultural tensions present beneath the mostly dominant cultural ethos of the Soviets, and who owned them?

The second floor exercise video is Emilia Eberle of Romania, competing in the Olympics in 1980. It isn’t the timeless 1979 World Championships floor exercise set to music by Boney M ('Brown Girl in the Ring' (1978)), but it does include the impression of a child having a tantrum that was so unforgettable in the 1979 version. The change of music barely makes a difference to the routine. I do have the feeling that Eberle manages to finesse this version perhaps a little more than she did a year earlier.

Reference

Dickie, G (1974) Art and the aesthetic Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tatyana Nabiyeva on work and love in China

Some highlights from a long interview with 2010 World champion Tatyana Nabiyeva.  Source: Russian team page on VK.com.  Translation - Google translate A big interview with Tatyana Nabieva about the peculiarities of work and life in China, the bright years of her sports career, a little about modern gymnastics and about love. On the Nabiyeva flight — At the same championship, you presented a new element on the bars, which was later added to the rules with your last name (flying over the top bar with a straight body, difficulty group F. — Sport24). How did you come up with the idea to try something new? — Actually, it happened spontaneously, I think. We worked with Vera Iosifovna [Kiryashova] on the purity of the elements on the bars, sometimes I didn’t fly all the way to the Shaposhnikova element. Once I didn’t fly all the way to the bars either and stood on my feet between the bars, bending my legs in flight for safety. Then Vera Iosifovna said that this was a different eleme...

‘We all love her very much’ - Roschina speaks of Mustafina and the need to perfect an Amanar vault

From sport.ru via vk.com.  Google translate  A big interview with Anastasia Loginova from Sport24 with Lyudmila Roshchina following the Strongest Cup, where the gymnast won four out of five gold medals. We quote several fragments, the full version is available on the publication's website, link at the end. ❓ The Strongest Athletes Cup has recently ended. Did you have time to analyze your performances? 💬 I just rewatched the broadcast, looked at my shortcomings. ❓ Did you set a medal plan for this start? 💬 I didn't think about it. Only that I needed to do my program - and then what will happen. ❓ Did you have time to discuss the competition with your coach? 💬 She praised me, said that I was great. She didn't scold me for mistakes on the beam - on the contrary, she supported me. ❓ Can we say that the beam is your weak spot? This is the only final you didn't get to. 💬 Probably yes. I have this apparatus that is a bit unpolished, so to speak. Treacherous. I need to work...

Angelina Melnikova photo session

Daria Isaeva has done a photo session with Angelina Melnikova at Dynamo Moscow.  Here are Angelina’s words about it.   "  The first time I was on a balance beam I was six years old. I was scared because of the height, so at first I walked hand in hand with my trainer." "The hardest thing on this apparatus is to keep your balance. Usually, when I'm on the beam, I imagine that I'm in a corridor 10 centimeters wide." "You can't be afraid of the beam! Coaches say that if you have fear, you will perform poorly." "The first difficult element I did at the age of eight was a backflip. In adult gymnastics, this element is considered one of the easiest." “I still can’t do a cartwheel on a log; I can easily fall off it, although children can do this element at the age of six.” "It's better to perform on the balance beam barefoot - you feel the apparatus better that way. But to avoid injuries, we sometimes tape our ankles." "It...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more