Skip to main content

The tragic end for Russian gymnastics

 

Russian gymnastics’ recent decision to withdraw its neutral athletes from international competition, as a protest over some offence or other, is highly uncharacteristic.  Only a few weeks ago, Russia was welcoming FIG President Watanabe into its gymnastics homes, with smiles and hugs exchanged at the highest level.  The gymnasts, including especially Angelina Melnikova, have been training assiduously for a return to the international arena.  There have been excited announcements of the names of those returning to our world of gymnastics.

 

Russian gymnastics has always been friendly, international and diplomatic.  Good sportsmanship is required of athletes and is generally shown, with a few notable exceptions.  During the depths of the Cold War, Russia’s teams toured the world, staging friendship displays and offering workshops and training.  Russian officials have been at the heart of the sport’s governance since the early 1990s and earlier this year many were re-elected to senior positions within the FIG. 

 

Recently, changes have been made to the running of the sport in Russia.  A new umbrella Russian Gymnastics Federation, covering all the different forms of the sport in Russia, has been established, with a new President, Oleg Belyozhorov, a former Deputy Minister of Transport and CEO of Russian Railways.  Artistic Gymnastics has its own discrete Federation, led by mostly the same people as before – Titov and the Rodionenkos.  It is unclear exactly who does the decision making, but it has so far seemed that Artistic Gymnastics has retained its independence and managed its athletes pretty much as before.  I repeat, it has SEEMED this way.

 

Thus we have had a great deal to look forward to now that Titov and the team have got together with Watanabe and formed opportunities for the gymnasts to compete, subject to clearance as neutral athletes.  The coaches have looked as inspired as the gymnasts at this result.  It has been a real diplomatic coup.

 

Perhaps rather too much of a coup for our friends at the Russian Gymnastics Federation (the ā€˜Bolshoi’ one).  While I’m pretty sure that the Rodionenkos were involved in negotiations with Watanabe, I’m almost equally sure that they are NOT behind the current decision to withdraw neutral athletes from international competition.  The old family do care about their athletes and coaches, and it would hurt their gymnasts and their organisation to rob them of competition.

 

So, while Valentina Rodionenko has a reputation for making – ahem – unusual decisions in the past, those decisions haven’t been overtly political and have usually been motivated for the good of the sport.  Andrei Rodionenko and the other senior coaches are models of tact and diplomacy.

 

And this withdrawal IS a political decision.  It mirrors the alienation of the West that is typical of Putin’s Russia at the moment, is high profile and matters to a lot of people.  I believe the decision to have been made by the new RGF President, Oleg Belyozhorov.  His organisation is bragging about the withdrawal of the gymnasts as if they had mined some gold. Belyozhorov is hugely rich, has no background in sport.  He won’t care about the future of a few 16 year olds, and would probably rather see them in battle dress.

 

Gymnastics, the most watched Olympic sport, is the poorer for Belyozhorov’s deliberate wastage of his country’s national talent.  For, it seems to me, this is the final stage for Russian gymnastics.  It is a tragedy.

 

 

Comments

  1. It's truly heartbreaking to witness the decline of Russian gymnastics, a sport that once symbolized excellence and diplomatic unity. The recent decision to withdraw neutral athletes from international competitions reflects a shift towards political tensions, overshadowing the sport's rich legacy. This move, seemingly orchestrated by figures with little understanding of gymnastics, risks squandering the immense talent Russia has nurtured over the years. It’s a tragedy not only for the athletes but for the global gymnastics community, which has always valued collaboration and sportsmanship. The future of Russian gymnastics remains uncertain, but it’s hard not to feel a sense of loss.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ukraine Olympic Committee calls for IOC to review Melnikova's neutral status

 I can share with you the letter dated 30 April.  The image quality is poor, but if you take your time you will be able to read it.   The reason for the review is not only Melnikova's registration as a candidate in Voronezh's regional elections, but also some fundraising events she has taken part in; and a picture of her with a 'Z' symbol, from the early part of the war. It seems that since Russia withdrew its gymnasts from competition - just a few weeks ago - opinions have hardened in favour of the War.  Melnikova has retained her silence, but others in the gymnastics community are speaking out in favour of Russia.   I'll not support these ideas.  But it's very easy for governments to influence their people.  Britain left the European Union on the back of some very questionable campaigning by leading politicians only a few years ago.  Donald Trump's government meetings are a quagmire of sycophantic nonsense as he destroys the world econ...

The Ukraine War and Russian female gymnasts

  War and violence are taken to be the domain of men, in the main … but women suffer too. The Russian female gymnasts are showing a few bruises.    Our ā€˜new generation’ of Kalmykova, Vasilieva, Roschina, Andreeva and others look well trained, but the lack of opportunity for overseas competition must be a severe disappointment.   24 year old Melnikova has commented that her career has crossed some very interesting times … the doping scandal with all its uncertainty, leading to neutral competition status for the team, Covid and the postponement of competitions, if not a battle with the illness itself for some individuals; and, now, the war with Ukraine, leading to sanctions against Russian competitors.    Finally, Russia’s rather pointless decision to ban themselves from competition as a kind of ā€˜protest’ against the neutral status they were seeking for so many of their team members.   The fact that Melnikova could carry away individual and tea...

Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics

Svetlana Boginskaya, 15 years old, with her medals from the Seoul Olympics Nico translates the latest interview with gymnastics legend Svetlana Boginskaya, during a recent visit to her home country of Belarus. Svetlana Boginskaya: I was always a bitch* in gymnastics, so now I ask for forgiveness from everyone who came in contact with me. The National Olympic Committee of Belarus held a press conference with three-time Olympic Champion in artistic gymnastics, Svetlana Boginskaya. The meeting was devoted to the 25th anniversary of the Olympic Games in Seoul. In South Korea the Belarussian won two gold medals in the team competition and vault. As a gift to the Olympic Hall of fame, the famous gymnast, now living in the United States, donated one of her trophies that she won at the 1990 European Championships and a pennant for Best Female Athlete of the USSR in 1989. How happy we were when we could share with such stars as Boginskaya, Scherbo, and Ivankov,...

RRG Archive - scroll by date, from 2024 to 2010

Show more